Do you think Sergio Martinez is overrated, if so, why?

[Ben_London]

He is totally underrated, most of the casual Boxing fans won't even know who he is. He's one of the best talents in my view.

[El Castigador]

The more you guys overrate him the better Williams looks.

[mangler jr]

The more you guys overrate him the better Williams looks.

He's not overrated. He's underrated.

He's top 5 p4p material. I'd put him past Mosley, Hopkins and Mayweather.

[El Castigador]

He's not overrated. He's underrated.

He's top 5 p4p material. I'd put him past Mosley, Hopkins and Mayweather.

He doesnt have one GOOD win on his resume.

[Ch@mpBox@PR]

Well For me is a very good fighter and very capable of beating anyone from 154-160.

But he also can be beaten. Even though I think he beat Williams, Quintana did a better job than Martinez in the first fight. Quintana hurt Paul as much, but didnt got hit back a much.. Martinez put the hurt on Williams but got hit plenty back.

I think he is very good, with solid skills and talent, but I wouldnt put him in the Mayweather, Mosley, Calderon league just yet

[JBell11]

Definitely NOT overrated. I agree with the other posts. Martinez has a great style, he can stick and move, he is evasive.

The citron/williams fights were very telling; the message? He can outbox the boxer. I think he has definitely earned the title as one of the "feared" fighters of his respective division(s). I think he outboxes Pavlik with ease.

[El Castigador]

Well For me is a very good fighter and very capable of beating anyone from 154-160.

But he also can be beaten. Even though I think he beat Williams, Quintana did a better job than Martinez in the first fight. Quintana hurt Paul as much, but didnt got hit back a much.. Martinez put the hurt on Williams but got hit plenty back.

I think he is very good, with solid skills and talent, but I wouldnt put him in the Mayweather, Mosley, Calderon league just yet

I cant put him with the elites until he starts beating people.

Fights with Dzindiruk, Angulo, Pavlik, Williams re-match will seal his legacy.

[2501]

I cant put him with the elites until he starts beating people.

Fights with Dzindiruk, Angulo, Pavlik, Williams re-match will seal his legacy.

One down and 3 more to go. Though I doubt they would put Angulo in with Martinez.

[B.U.R.N.E.R]

One down and 3 more to go. Though I doubt they would put Angulo in with Martinez.

He still needs to rematch Paul and avenge his loss. Hes good but some people are going over the top.

[Dirk Diggler UK]

He's underrated if anything. People rank Paul Williams in their top 4/5 p4p but dont rate Sergio at all...wtf? He didnt just outbox them, he sent both Williams and Pavlik to the hospital.