Is Miguel Angel Cotto a Hall of Famer??

[tesla_power]

No. Vacant titles, Top Rank matchmaking. Lost his two truly meaningful fights by a landslide.

Come on. Vacant titles or not. Care to compare your favorite fighter's JWW and WW resume against Cotto?

[savorduhflavor]

He's a HOF. That's a mixture of his resume, exciting fights, and how easy the Boxing HOF is to get into.

His run at 140 is criminally underrated. And a lot of people think he's the best Welterweight of the decade top to bottom.

[WhoreUs!]

no he isn't
if he can come back he might get in
he looks done though

[PR13]

Really? I heard he got a good ass whoopin' from a midget.


j/k

but he's one of the best and not the best.

Too bad your midget is on Roids

[FlomoFoLyfe]

I say yes. He has the best WW resume of anyone in the last decade.

Yes.

Do I think your a fruit cup?

Yes.

[FlomoFoLyfe]

Too bad your midget is on Roids

Who gets beat by a midget on steroids?

Oh yeah, Cotto did.

[Iceta Lives]

No, he's not. If he is, then Madison Square Garden has helped him get there.

[PR13]

Who gets beat by a midget on steroids?

Oh yeah, Cotto did.

Thats true, thanx for admiting he uses steroids

[HaglerSteelChin]

THere was a discussion on the boxing history forum on this topic few months ago. I think he needs another big win at 154 to get a 3rd weight class and that will increase his chances. Of course, his only two losses will be debated but they are still officially losses and not ruled as NC.

[Marijuana]

Come on. Vacant titles or not. Care to compare your favorite fighter's JWW and WW resume against Cotto?

JWW and WW are Cotto's first 2 divisions. The fair comparison would be to compare that resume to Floyd's first 2 divisions, SFW and LW. Hernandez, Corrales, Chavez, Castillo 2x. Undefeated. Actually took the title from 2 champs. 11 total title defenses.

Compare that pendejo.