Is Pac greater than SRL?

[El Chicano]

Give it up. I presented logical reasons in an earlier post. I am a big Pacquaio fan and put him Top 25. Beating Mayweather will put him Top 15. Unfortunately, as far as you are concerned, Leonard is Top 10.

Many, many people share this view.

Whatever mocoso.

You've already given up. You mentioned the Benitez, Duran, Hearns and Hagler wins as the reason you'd rate Ray above Manny.

Manny's win over MAB is better than the Benitez win hands down.

Manny's KOs over Morales in the rematch and rubber match equal Ray's win over Duran (Duran was best at 135). Morales is a lock for the HOF.

Manny moving up two weight classes to stop Oscar and then move back DOWN to KTFO Ricky in two rounds (two more lock HOF fighters) is unheard of. Everyone was in awe of what Manny did to these great fighters. Easily equal to if not surpasses Ray's difficult win over Tommy.

And Ray lost to Marvin. Many will agree with me on that.

Manny's TKO win over Cotto, possibly the best Welter in the division, winning a championship in his 7th weight class is simply amazing and again, unheard of.

With that said, Manny is as good or better than Ray on the ATG list. Don't get all caught up with **** you know nothing about youngster.

[andrewcuff]

Whatever mocoso.

You've already given up. You mentioned the Benitez, Duran, Hearns and Hagler wins as the reason you'd rate Ray above Manny.

Manny's win over MAB is better than the Benitez win hands down.

Manny's KOs over Morales in the rematch and rubber match equal Ray's win over Duran (Duran was best at 135). Morales is a lock for the HOF.

Manny moving up two weight classes to stop Oscar and then move back DOWN to KTFO Ricky in two rounds (two more lock HOF fighters) is unheard of. Everyone was in awe of what Manny did to these great fighters. Easily equal to if not surpasses Ray's difficult win over Tommy.

And Ray lost to Marvin. Many will agree with me on that.

Manny's TKO win over Cotto, possibly the best Welter in the division, winning a championship in his 7th weight class is simply amazing and again, unheard of.

With that said, Manny is as good or better than Ray on the ATG list. Don't get all caught up with **** you know nothing about youngster.

Wins over HOF fighters are better than wins over ATGs? No.

How is the Barrera win more significant than than the Benitez win? It isn't.

Hearns was a much better fighter than Oscar and Hatton. More impressive.

The Cotto was was unbelieveable, yes and far more convincing than Leonard vs Hagler.

But...Leonard beat 4 ATGs and Pacman hasn't.


Don't get all caught up with **** you know nothing about youngster. - Give it a rest. No need to be so arrogant simply because I pointed out valid reasons why Leonard is ranked higher.

[donkim]

Try to ignore M@nny,he's not a boxing fan,nor does he know a thing about the sport unless somebody can justify Pacquiao knocking out Ricky Hatton as being more impressive than stopping Thomas Hearns.


I've yet to see a Pacquiao fan who does actually know a thing about boxing to be honest.

[andrewcuff]

Try to ignore M@nny,he's not a boxing fan,nor does he know a thing about the sport unless somebody can justify Pacquiao knocking out Ricky Hatton as being more impressive than stopping Thomas Hearns.


I've yet to see a Pacquiao fan who does actually know a thing about boxing to be honest.

Oi! I'm a Pacquiao fan LOL.

[El Chicano]

Wins over HOF fighters are better than wins over ATGs? No.

How is the Barrera win more significant than than the Benitez win? It isn't.

Hearns was a much better fighter than Oscar and Hatton. More impressive.

The Cotto was was unbelieveable, yes and far more convincing than Leonard vs Hagler.

But...Leonard beat 4 ATGs and Pacman hasn't.


Don't get all caught up with **** you know nothing about youngster. - Give it a rest. No need to be so arrogant simply because I pointed out valid reasons why Leonard is ranked higher.

Here you go with your BoxRec knowledge youngster. Now you've reverted to... "Leonard beat 4 ATGs and Pacman hasn't." Loser

MAB, Erik & JMM will be higher on the ATG list than Benitez, learn your ****.

Oscar is equal to Tommy on the list.

Duran while an ATG at LIGHTWEIGHT was outmatched at WELTERWEIGHT. And Duran beat him in the first fight!

And you already stated that Manny's win over Cotto was more significant than Leanard's loss to Marvin.

You keep trying to convince us but you are just not convincing.

[Kiid Dynamite]

Not necessarily. It would depend on the nature of the win. A close decision would be less impressive than Leonards wins over Duran & Hearns 147. However, "doing a Hatton" job on Floyd would really make things close.

Then again Leonard vs Hagler is hugely debatable and you use it as part of Leonards legacy over pacs

hypocrite