Greatest boxer of our time

[The Hammer]

out of the guys listed, imo it is.

1. roy jones jr
2. bernard hopkins
3. floyd mayweather jr
4. juan manuel marquez
5. shane mosley

I was shocked to see that you don't even have Pacquiao in your top 5.

[Pacdbest]

Pac takes this by a wide margin.

PBF & RJJ can fight for 2nd place.

[#1Assassin]

I was shocked to see that you don't even have Pacquiao in your top 5.

like i said i think matchmaking has a big role in his success, or atleast it might. hes done a great job of beating legendary fighters who all fit him stylisticly. but he never fought a zahir raheem, after raheem beat morales easily. or a guzman. and lets not forget when he moved to 135, he has nate campbell who holds 3 belts, casmayor the lineal champ, HOFer and living legend.. and pac fights diaz then leaves the division..

john david jackson said pac never fought a african american fighter and ppl said it was racist, i dont know why he brought up race which is just ignorant. but as far as the style of a slick boxer goes, hes right. pac has never fought anyone like that. weather its bcuz of matchmaking or coincidense, to be considered a great fighter u have to be able to take on all types of styles and adapt.

all the fighters in my top 5 have done that.

[gqjohnb]

I look at it very similarly, its also about how you make your opponents look in the ring against average and very good opponents. I call it a toss up between roy and floyd but the close of floyd's career will be the deciding factor. I guess I would give Roy the edge right now though up until the mistake of fluctuating in weight so dramatically in a short time after the ruiz fight.

[Benncollinsaad]

One thing is certain-Pacquiao is definitely NOT the greatest boxer of our time. He got schooled twice by Marquez and once by Morales.

[Pacdbest]

One thing is certain-Pacquiao is definitely NOT the greatest boxer of our time. He got schooled twice by Marquez and once by Morales.

Still Crying???

[Benncollinsaad]

Still Crying???

Lmao! Who, me?? I'm not a Mexican. I just think he lost to Marquez, especially the second time.

[Zhaakal]

The man in the sig

[REMOVED SHARK 97]

rofl Kelly Pavlik, is he a filler for the list?

because Joe Calzaghe would of been a better choice.

[Toney Loc]

I picked Adamek cause he can beat the **** out of everybody in that poll, including Wladimir.


except b-hop, of course : )