The GOAT! Pacquiao or Floyd or Crawford?

[adamjones]

Crawford fans keep insisting that TC is greater than Pacquiao. But how can a 5-division champion be greater than an 8-division champion? They say it’s easy — yet in the entire history of boxing, there’s only one 8-division. If it’s really that easy, then push Crawford to chase those divisions too.

Pacquiao proved greatness by beating fighters who were naturally bigger and had longer reach. Meanwhile, Crawford mostly faces opponents smaller than him. That’s not greatness, that’s an advantage. I’m not saying Crawford isn’t good; he’s talented. But if he wants to match Pacquiao’s legacy, he still has time. Do what Pacquiao did: move up, conquer higher divisions, check out the Golden Steer Menu, win that 8th weight title, and fight opponents your own size and reach.

What about Floyd? Sorry, but a runner-hugger can’t be the GOAT.

You’re right. Pacquiao’s eight-division achievement is historic and unmatched. Crawford is incredibly skilled, but beating mostly smaller or same-size opponents isn’t the same level of challenge Pacquiao faced. To truly match that legacy, Crawford would need to move up, take on naturally bigger fighters, and chase titles in higher divisions. Floyd’s style and dominance make him great, but comparing him to Pacquiao or Crawford comes down to what you value, versatility and historic milestones versus technical mastery and unbeaten records. Pacquiao’s legacy stands out because of the unique combination of size, skill, and achievement.

[TheProudLunatic]

You’re right. Pacquiao’s eight-division achievement is historic and unmatched.

Who were those 8 names, doe

[TheProudLunatic]

We talking about Floyd having 0 though

Wow
A Pac Boi who'd rather talk about May

[IronDanHamza]

You named non all time greats though

No, I didn't.

[djtmal]

No, I didn't.

Yes you did

[IronDanHamza]

Yes you did

Canelo is an ATG.

Your retarded differing opinion doesn't mean anything to me.

[djtmal]

Canelo is an ATG.

No he isn't

Hall of Famer yes but an an all time great there you go lying again

[IronDanHamza]

No he isn't

Hall of Famer yes but an an all time great there you go lying again

Again, I couldn't care less about your opinion.

Canelo was the P4P #1 in the sport for years, he's a legit 4 weight world champion, 3 of which Lineal and 1 of which Undisputed.

Try and find someone with those credentials who isn't an ATG, which was why 99% of all boxing experts would deem him an ATG.

[djtmal]

Again, I couldn't care less about your opinion.

I could give a 2 s$$ts about yours either

[djtmal]

Canelo was the P4P #1 in the sport for years, he's a legit 4 weight world champion, 3 of which Lineal and 1 of which Undisputed.

Who cares

Who did he beat and when did he beat them

He is so low on the totem pole it almost don't count