Announcement

Collapse
No announcement yet.

Using "Ring Magazine top ten Ranked Heavyweight" is again shown to be a poor measure.

Collapse
  • Filter
  • Time
  • Show
Clear All
new posts

  • Using "Ring Magazine top ten Ranked Heavyweight" is again shown to be a poor measure.

    Justis Huni performed very well on Saturday against British contender Fabio Wardley, up by 88-83, 89-82, 89-82 before getting stopped in his tracks by a Wardley right hand.

    Huni performed nearly as well as Wardley's countryman Frazer Clarke had done in that pair's first meeting back in March of last year, when Wardley was pressed to a draw.


    Huni, though unsuccessful in his first attempt to break into the world class tier, might in fact have upped his stock, with his smooth performance, at least in the eyes of observers who insist that a fighter's accomplishments weigh more heavily toward a high ranking than do the ranker's prognostications regarding the prospect's chances in future challenges.


    The staff at the old Victory Sports Series publications and Boxing Illustrated, decades ago; would often marvel at our competitor's faith in the Ring staffers ability predict the road ahead for prospects like Huni, and award them a high rating before it was earned.


    The right hand of Wardley this weekend, serves as the most recent example of procedure vindication for that conservative approach, as Huni is dropped from The Ring's top 10, and replaced this morning by Wardley, and joins the long list of The Ring's top ten ranked heavyweights who were overestimated when chosen for inclusion in their top ten, as were Randy Neumann, Howard "KO" Smith, Johnny Boudreaux, Marty Monroe, Domingo D'Elia, Adilson Rodrigues, Orlin Norris, Michael Bentt, Phil Jackson, Mike "The Bounty" Hunter, Lionel Butler, Alexander Zolkin, Derrick Jefferson, Fres Oquendo, Kirk Johnson, Monty Barrett, Calvin Brock, Vladimir Virchis (Vyrchyis), Alexander Dimitrenko and Denis Boystov, in recent decades. Each one a "top 10 ranked Heavyweight"; thr term so often used here at Boxing Scene by fans groping to assign a seal of excellence. But Huni is young, and has the opportunity to use this loss productively to improve with.


    Fabio Wardley, for his part, is continuing to chop away at excellent opponents, and like Kabayel and Parker, proceeds ahead on building his case amongst his contemporaries.​
    JakeTheBoxer JakeTheBoxer likes this.

  • #2
    Huni lost but by last nights performance id have him above Wardley. Huni was so far ahead he could have been cautious but was looking for a ko or something? Id give Huni bonus points for coming in short notice too.
    MulaKO MulaKO likes this.

    Comment


    • #3
      Huni lost, but his future is brighter rhan Wardley's.
      MulaKO MulaKO likes this.

      Comment


      • #4
        The TBRB has been 50X better than The Ring since day one.

        Comment


        • #5
          Its all just an opinion.

          But The Rings rankings are based on Independent panelists of historians and writers from around the world.

          Doesn't get much less bias than that.

          Obviously wrong sometimes, but the bookies almost got it horribly wrong yesterday too, and they hate being wrong.
          Dr Z Dr Z likes this.

          Comment


          • #6
            Originally posted by M312 View Post
            Its all just an opinion.

            But The Rings rankings are based on Independent panelists of historians and writers from around the world.

            Doesn't get much less bias than that.

            Obviously wrong sometimes, but the bookies almost got it horribly wrong yesterday too, and they hate being wrong.
            The Ring isn't independent and hasn't been for a very long time. That's why their entire editorial board at one point resigned and left to form the TBRB.

            The Ring is a promotional tool of the Saudi government at this point. Prior to that they were a promotional tool of Golden Boy.

            The TBRB is independent. Their rankings are objective. The Ring is the opposite, they are both a government entity AND a promotional tool. That's a double death knell for journalism.
            Coverdale Coverdale likes this.

            Comment


            • #7
              Huni was never in the rings top 10. Wardley was ranked 10th and has been for a bit. It literally says on the site updated June 4th...so your entire argument is wrong even though it's not a good argument to begin with.
              Dr Z Dr Z Coverdale Coverdale like this.

              Comment

              Working...
              X
              TOP