Inoue or wilder? Bigger puncher?

[Nash out]

Didn't wilder direct message joshua on social media and say let's fight for 50 million. Then when Joshua said let's see the contract wilder Said no lol. I love how that has been mischaracterized as an offer to fight. It's just a guy running his mouth and getting his bluff called. Joshua literally sent wilder a contract offer for 100 million. Like on paper sign on the dotted line and it's official. Wilder Siad no to that. Joshua said no to something that never existed.

Nash was in attendance (they needed someone from the Boxingscene Hall of Fame as witness) when Wilder counted out every dollar in front of Joshua and Earn with Hearn.Nash out - His Majesty

[Bennyleonard99]

While Inoue is the real deal I think Wilder is vastly overrated and a hype job. If his power was so terrifying, Haymon would have had the confidence to put him in with AJ Usyk and Whyte, and not just a blubberhouse fading circus clown (Fury). You see, Wilder was built on PBC set ups and then after the phony record was established, they targeted the clearly in decline Fury. Fury never was as good as he was after beating Klitschko. Wilder's power wasn't evident vs Fury, Zhang, he only really beat PBC set ups. Wilder may be the most overrated overhyped heavyweight contender in history. And we all know Al Haymon had the logistics and unethical tendencies to fabricate Deontay Wilder. To fill the void of there being no good American heavyweights.

[MalevolentBite]

There's so many gray areas in this loaded question. I wouldnt know how to answer. P4P inoue. However if you offered me money. I rather take a punch from Inoue with gloves on then the Windmill Deontay wilder. Deontay only knows how to throw haymakers. From a career standpoint up to the 3rd Tyson Fury fight it is proven if Deontay CAN land that haymaker you are going to get dropped badly.

Tyson Fury was able to absorb those haymakers because he outweighed Deontay by 60lbs atleast. I can take inoues best punch at 200lbs (roughly what i weigh) But I am not taking Deontay haymaker if the money is the same.

P4P - Inoue.

Overall if he actually lands - Deontay pre Fury.

[The Big Dunn]

You can settle this for yourself daggum.

Let them both get a free punch in your face.

Wilder should go first because he is older. If you wake up , then let Inoue go.

Them you tell all of us.

[billeau2]

Who was the bigger puncher?

Innoue 16-0 with 14 kos(87.5%) against top 10 ring ranked opponents


wilder 3-4-1 with 2 kos(25%) agaisnt top 10 ring ranked opponents

Ridiculous measure of comparison. Who cares about ring ranked opponents?

You also cannot compare heavyweights to the lighter divisions. They're just different dynamics entirely.

You keep writing these troll threads because you cannot appreciate skills Wilder had as a puncher.

[billeau2]

Wilder was great against those bums he lined up or guys like Scott who went down untouched. Strangely it didn't transfer to top level

Yes it did... He almost beat Fury. Remember?

[SUBZER0ED]

Your poll is skewed, daggum. The title asks who was the bigger puncher, but the criteria for the vote is vs top 10 opponents. Everyone knows that Wilder's skill set was inferior to Inuoe's, which is why he was carefully matched for years. However, Deontay's punching power cannot be denied. If he landed that right hand, it was nite nite 9.9 times out of 10.

[SUBZER0ED]

You can settle this for yourself daggum.

Let them both get a free punch in your face.

Wilder should go first because he is older. If you wake up , then let Inoue go.

Them you tell all of us.

If Wilder catches him right, he may go see Jesus.

[billeau2]

Your poll is skewed, daggum. The title asks who was the bigger puncher, but the criteria for the vote is vs top 10 opponents. Everyone knows that Wilder's skill set was inferior to Inuoe's, which is why he was carefully matched for years. However, Deontay's punching power cannot be denied. If he landed that right hand, it was nite nite 9.9 times out of 10.

Apparently the jaw of a ring ranked fighter is different

[daggum]

Apparently the jaw of a ring ranked fighter is different

It is different. Being a top fighter is a self selecting system. The guys who can't take a punch usually don't make it to the top. Those that can do. That's why it's much harder to knock out ranked fighters. They don't go down so easily as wilder found out yet you still have people on here judging him based on what he did vs the crappy fighters he fought.