Who had the better career at Welterweight: Pacquiao or Crawford?

[HisExcellency]

1) Spence crushes everyone Pac fought, except May.

2) Let's take a look .....
Shopworn Eric 3x
Shopworn Marco 2x
Decent W's
Typical plodding, 1 gear, face first types
Ditto JMM 2x
Perfect Pac opp.
Willing to stand there and trade !

Now for the hysterical portion of his resume. The portion too painful for you to discuss IN DETAIL -

DONE La Hoya (absolutely the worst version)
Hatton (May did it 1st. Hatton never amounted to anything other than a fan favorite)
Cotto Lite (the worst version and this is not up for debate)
Clottey (typical journeyman)
Margarito (worst version)
Mosley (worst version)
JMM 3 & 4 ( 4x ?!?!?)
Timmeh 3x ( 3x ?!?!?!)
Baby Margarito ( Brandon Rios on Pacquiao loss: I was never hurt, but Manny was too fast)
Alcherry
May ( who's older than Pac with 2 damaged fists. Pac losing so many times before their fight is Pac's fault. They could have fought much sooner if Pac agreed to RANDOM BLOOD tests )
Vargas ( )
HORN (CPGW) !!!!
Lucas (See Vargas)
Almost Bumlevel
Sometime (after a 15 mon layoff to let some booboos heal from a previous fight. Pac's best WW W, thanks to a flash KD)
Basic AF Ugas.

So tell me, which of the above fights is supposed to impress me

Now do the SAME type of analysis on both Crawford & Mayweather’s CV’s and I’ll reply…

[TheProudLunatic]

Now do the SAME type of analysis on both Crawford & Mayweather’s CV’s and I’ll reply…

I don't have a problem with theirs
You do

[Century Tuna]

Speaking of washed up, over the hill champs, wasn't that Crawford I saw in the ring getting his hand raised for beating Amir Khan with a low blow

Lmao the glass-chinned Indian ran off. Everyone knows he quit. Just looking for an excuse before Crawford folded him like a lawn chair.

[HisExcellency]

I don't have a problem with theirs
You do

Ahahahahahahahaha!

Crawford's Welterweight CV:-

Spence (post life-changing car crash & years of hard partying. Only fought TWICE in the 3.5 years preceding their fight)
Porter (post 3 losses)
Khan (post 4 losses & 3 KO's)
Brook (post 2 KO's and having both eye sockets broken)
Benavidez Jr (BUM)
Avenesyan (BUM)
Mean Machine (BUM)
Horn (BUM - this bum got a hometown decision against Manny who outlanded him 11 rounds to 1 and 182 vs. 92 punches overall according to CompuBox)

Yep...Bud definitely has the BETTER CV at Welterweight!

[TheProudLunatic]

Ahahahahahahahaha!

Crawford's Welterweight CV:-

Spence (post life-changing car crash & years of hard partying. Only fought TWICE in the 3.5 years preceding their fight)
Porter (post 3 losses)
Khan (post 4 losses & 3 KO's)
Brook (post 2 KO's and having both eye sockets broken)
Benavidez Jr (BUM)
Avenesyan (BUM)
Mean Machine (BUM)
Horn (BUM - this bum got a hometown decision against Manny who outlanded him 11 rounds to 1 and 182 vs. 92 punches overall according to CompuBox)

Yep...Bud definitely has the BETTER CV at Welterweight!

Spence > Everyone Pac fought, except May

HORN would agree

[TheProudLunatic]

Porter (post 3 losses)

Pac opps that Porter would beat -
Rios
Alcherry
Vargas
Lucas
Almost Bumlevel
Hatton
HORN
DONE la Hoya
Clottey
JMM
Margarito

Maybe Ugas

[TheProudLunatic]

Pac opps Brook would beat -
Rios
Almost Bumlevel
Lucas
Vargas
DONE La Hoya
Margarito
Hatton
HORN
Alcherry
Mosley
Clottey

Maybe Cotto LITE and Ugas

[TheProudLunatic]

How so called fight fans and experts say Pac has a great resume is baffling.
Name recognition only.
No one questions the quality of those names WHEN Pac fought them !

[HisExcellency]

Mayweather's CV

Castillo 1 (Mayweather clearly LOST the fight and the CompuBox punch stats were 203 vs. 157 in Castillo's favour)
Gatti (post 6 losses & 2 KO's at the end of his career)
Judah (post 3 losses & 1 KO plus Judah dropped Mayweather which wasn't counted)
ODLH (post 4 losses & 1 KO and a SD win for Mayweather which even his own daddy said he LOST)
Hatton (beat Ricky in only his 2nd fight at Welterweight instead of destroying him in his natural weight class like Manny)
JMM (post 4 losses and multiple knockdowns by Pacquiao. Mayweather fought him at a catchweight but decided to come in heavier himself)
Mosley (post 5 losses yet Mosley almost decapitated Mayweather in the 2nd round. Imagine what he would've done in his prime?)
Ortiz (post 1 KO and cheated to get the victory after taking advantage of Victor's sportsmanship to get the KO)
Cotto (post 2 losses & 2 KO's)
Guerrero (post 1 loss and an average fighter at best)
Canelo (fought a green 23yo Canelo at a catchweight)
Maidana 1 (post 3 losses and a MD win for Mayweather which he arguably lost given that the CompuBox punch stats were narrowly (230 vs. 221) in his favour)
Pacquiao (post 5 losses and 3 KO's after avoiding him in his prime when he was dangerous a decade earlier)
Berto (post 3 losses and 1 KO and an average fighter at best)
McGregor (never boxed a day in his life lmao)

Did I miss anyone?

[TheProudLunatic]

Mayweather's CV

Castillo 1 (Mayweather clearly LOST the fight and the CompuBox punch stats were 203 vs. 157 in Castillo's favour)
Gatti (post 6 losses & 2 KO's at the end of his career)
Judah (post 3 losses & 1 KO plus Judah dropped Mayweather which wasn't counted)
ODLH (post 4 losses & 1 KO and a SD win for Mayweather which even his own daddy said he LOST)
Hatton (beat Ricky in only his 2nd fight at Welterweight instead of destroying him in his natural weight class like Manny)
JMM (post 4 losses and multiple knockdowns by Pacquiao. Mayweather fought him at a catchweight but decided to come in heavier himself)
Mosley (post 5 losses yet Mosley almost decapitated Mayweather in the 2nd round. Imagine what he would've done in his prime?)
Ortiz (post 1 KO and cheated to get the victory after taking advantage of Victor's sportsmanship to get the KO)
Cotto (post 2 losses & 2 KO's)
Guerrero (post 1 loss and an average fighter at best)
Canelo (fought a green 23yo Canelo at a catchweight)
Maidana 1 (post 3 losses and a MD win for Mayweather which he arguably lost given that the CompuBox punch stats were narrowly (230 vs. 221) in his favour)
Pacquiao (post 5 losses and 3 KO's after avoiding him in his prime when he was dangerous a decade earlier)
Berto (post 3 losses and 1 KO and an average fighter at best)
McGregor (never boxed a day in his life lmao)

Did I miss anyone?

Castillo > Erik, Marco, JMM
And no. He did not win the 1st fight.

Gatti > Rios, Lucas, Almost Bumlevel, Mosely, Clottey, Hatrton, DONE La Hoya
DLH > Everyone Pac fought, including Pac
Zab > Everyone Pac fought
Cotto > Pac without a clause !
Young Nelo would absolutely destroy everyone Pac fought including Pac !!!!
On and On..........

You're a funny guy