Announcement

Collapse
No announcement yet.

So who is PFP Number 1

Collapse
  • Filter
  • Time
  • Show
Clear All
new posts

  • #11
    P4P is just some subjective fantasy list that dont mean much so there are no wrong answers.

    Inoue leaves no doubts so it’s him.

    Didn’t Usyk already get knocked out by Dubois? Bunch of people were talking about this leading up to the Fury fight but it’s getting swept under the rug now.

    Atypicalbrit Atypicalbrit likes this.

    Comment


    • #12
      Inoue is still #1.

      I think Fury’s level was considerably lowered based on his performance against a first time boxer in Ngannou. He got knocked down and almost lost on pts vs even a smaller man. I question his skills and chin.

      I can never see a first time mma boxer do that to Inoue or Crawford.

      Comment


      • #13
        Originally posted by FinitoxDinamita View Post
        P4P is just some subjective fantasy list that dont mean much so there are no wrong answers.

        Inoue leaves no doubts so it’s him.

        Didn’t Usyk already get knocked out by Dubois? Bunch of people were talking about this leading up to the Fury fight but it’s getting swept under the rug now.
        I don’t think It’s getting swept under the rug.

        I think we have to go with actual results.

        Inoue at #1 isn’t bad in any way.

        Comment


        • #14
          Originally posted by The Big Dunn View Post

          I don’t think It’s getting swept under the rug.

          I think we have to go with actual results.

          Inoue at #1 isn’t bad in any way.
          I agree with the actual result too but there were several recent threads that tried to discredit Usyk for getting unofficially KO’d and all those posters are quiet now as if it never happened.

          Comment


          • #15
            Originally posted by FinitoxDinamita View Post

            I agree with the actual result too but there were several recent threads that tried to discredit Usyk for getting unofficially KO’d and all those posters are quiet now as if it never happened.
            Bro, you’re a veteran of the site. You know how that goes. lol.
            crimsonfalcon07 crimsonfalcon07 likes this.

            Comment


            • #16
              Fury was bigger than usyk. But many think fury has only had the success he's had because of his dimensions, over his rivals. And if Fury didn't have that height, or reach hed be found wanting. But fury did make usyk look rather human even ordinary at times in middle rounds.
              Fury isn't especially fast, or powerful.
              Its not like fury is a pfp fighter, and why is usyk being given such credit for beating someone coming off terrible performance?
              I think usyk is no2 pfp
              Last edited by hugh grant; 05-20-2024, 04:18 PM.

              Comment


              • #17
                Usyk, Crawford, and Inoue are all legitimate choices. Nobody else is in the conversation.

                Inoue has the best activity, belts in 4 divisions, wins in 5 divisions, undisputed and lineal in 2 divisions, 14-0 vs top 10, 14-0 vs world titlists, 9-0 vs top 5
                Usyk just beat a guy 40 pounds heavier, undisputed and lineal in 2 divisions, 7-0 vs top 10, 8-0 vs world titlists, 5-0 vs top 5, 10-0 on the road
                Crawford is one of only 9 three division lineal champions ever, undisputed in 2 divisions, 13-0 vs top 10, 10-0 vs world titlists, 8-0 vs top 5

                You can put them in any order and not be wrong. I have Crawford because I still think 3 lineal titles is the biggest accomplishment on the list, but if Inoue keeps getting 2 or 3 wins to every 1 for Crawford it's hard to argue against him. Usyk has similar activity issues to Crawford, but since he's the oldest guy on the list with the longest amateur career that's understandable.
                Last edited by famicommander; 05-20-2024, 04:00 PM.

                Comment


                • #18
                  Crawford, and not even close. Please.

                  Comment


                  • #19
                    Inoue

                    It's not that he's winning it's HOW he's winning.

                    Even at cruiserweight Usyk had a hard fight with Bredis and Bellew gave him more problems than he had any right to.

                    When I think of a P4P great I think of a dominator, a guy who makes his peers look like they don't belong in the same ring with him and that's inoue.

                    Usyk vs a 6'3" 220lb Inoue who wins, for me it's Inumoue all day long.

                    ​​​​​​Bud Crawford is just too inactive, I can't put a guy that inactive high up the list, it's a spectator sport and he's giving the spectators nothing.
                    Last edited by Atypicalbrit; 05-20-2024, 05:08 PM.

                    Comment


                    • #20
                      Originally posted by JOITATS View Post
                      Inoue is still #1.

                      He got knocked down and almost lost on pts vs even a smaller man. .
                      eh just a small note, ngannou is almost 275 pounds and hes ripped, hes a big guy who can punch, AJ just the right thing and punched him hard first

                      Comment

                      Working...
                      X
                      TOP