Comments Thread For: Tarver Backs Crawford as P4P Best: How Many P4P Champions Has Inoue Defeated?

[IronDanHamza]

If spence is worthy of being pfp on basis of beating Garcia and porter, then so is fulton, and Tapales. Id pick them to best spence. Fulton took inoue punches without much issue round after round and spence don't hit as hard as inoue.
Inoue beating Fulton in 1st fight in division makes it a greater win than buds win over spence

I don’t know can I ask this question easier for you to understand.

If Spence has beaten no one good, who has Fulton beat?

[_Rexy_]

I have never called Indongo or Jeff Horn elite; However, Errol Spence, Jr was. In any case, has any of those guys ever made the P4P list?

I believe Fulton has but I am not too sure.Also, didn't Stephen Fulton win a controversial decision against Brandon Figueroa; In which most boxing fans felt that he lost?.

Fulton was top 10

Didn’t Spence win a controversial decision against Shawn Porter, in which most boxing fans felt he lost?

[Bravado]

Fulton was top 10

Didn’t Spence win a controversial decision against Shawn Porter, in which most boxing fans felt he lost?

I mean didn’t Fulton?

[_Rexy_]

I mean didn’t Fulton?

That’s what I was responding to. He mentioned Fulton close win, so I mentioned Spence’s.

[hugh grant]

I don’t know can I ask this question easier for you to understand.

If Spence has beaten no one good, who has Fulton beat?

Im not saying spence has beat absolute cans. But does struggling to best fighters in your division make you pf p wirthy? Fulton not beaten anyone of note too that comes to mind. So I don't think you can keep going wow, bud best a pf p fighter like it's some real big deal.
Bud can best the 2 best fighters in the 154 division in his first fights then that is equal to inoue

[IronDanHamza]

Im not saying spence has beat absolute cans. But does struggling to best fighters in your division make you pf p wirthy? Fulton not beaten anyone of note too that comes to mind. So I don't think you can keep going wow, bud best a pf p fighter like it's some real big deal.
Bud can best the 2 best fighters in the 154 division in his first fights then that is equal to inoue

So, you’re saying Fulton, arguably Inoue’s best win, hasn’t beaten anyone good.

Ok nice one.

[Jab jab boom]

When Inoue beat Donaire, he was the age Crawford was when he beat Spence.

But yeah, Fulton, Rodriguez, Tapales, paper champions. Jeff Horn, Indongo, elite

False. Donaire was 2 yrs older than what Crawford is now when he gave Inoue hell and was 4 yrs older than what Crawford is now for the rematch. Not to mention donaire had several losses, a lot of wear and tear by the time he faced Inoue. Crawford didn’t have that kind of mileage.

[Jab jab boom]

Tarver is siding with his fellow Afroamerican and being racist. Just because Inoue is from a small weight class and fights in Japan does mot mean he is not worthy of p4p credentials.

Imagine accusing someone else of being racist while you’re using the term Afro American.

[IronDanHamza]

False. Donaire was 2 yrs older than what Crawford is now when he gave Inoue hell and was 4 yrs older than what Crawford is now for the rematch. Not to mention donaire had several losses, a lot of wear and tear by the time he faced Inoue. Crawford didn’t have that kind of mileage.

It’s at best disingenuous to even compare that verison of Crawford to the verison of Donaire Inoue beat, at worst retarded.

Inoue’s an elite fighter, arguably the best in the world right now but these fanboys of him are very weird.

[richardt]

I'm going with Crawford by a small margin but I am quite comfortable with my pick. Now I hope to see who is in the running in a year from now.