If Canelo Beats Beanvidez he's clearly the best 168 of all time

[MikeyMike100]

No, not even close how long have some of you been watching if you think his reign is the best ever at 168?

Only one that compares is Ward but with the Benavidez win Canelo will have the edge

[MikeyMike100]

So would Benny be the greatest if he beats Canelo ?
Cause that narrative would have to go long , it’s a two way street or one way ?
Calzaghe would beat both of them
RJJ would obliterate them
Just sayin’

No cause Benavidez doesnt have the depth in wins that Canelo has.

[_Rexy_]

I think he already probably is but if he beat Benavidez its not even debatable imo

Rocky Fielding
Callum Smith
Avni Yildrim
Billy Joe Saunders
Caleb Plant
GGG
John Ryder
David Benavidez

Undefeated and no one would have a better resume at 168 than this

LMFAO this is a troll thread right?

[MulaKO]

No cause Benavidez doesnt have the depth in wins that Canelo has.

But he beat them #1 didn’t he
That is why your way of thinking doesn’t work

[Spray_resistant]

Only one that compares is Ward but with the Benavidez win Canelo will have the edge

No, he won't its been covered by other posters in this thread but even fighters in his era he beat have a better resume at 168 than Canelo.

[The D3vil]

The delusion of these Canelo stans.

I think you can count Plant & Benavidez as quality wins, but the rest of those are trash.

GGG beat him twice at 160 & Canelo finally legitimately beat him when he was 157 years old in a new weight class

[MikeyMike100]

LMFAO this is a troll thread right?

I forgot Jermell Charlo but I dont really value that win that much.

Can you name another SMW in history that would have a better top 9 wins at SMW than Canelo would if he beat Benavidez

[MikeyMike100]

But he beat them #1 didn’t he
That is why your way of thinking doesn’t work

Just cause you beat someone doesn't mean you inherit their resume. Obviously Buster Douglas didnt surpass Mike Tyson on an all time scale

[MikeyMike100]

No, he won't its been covered by other posters in this thread but even fighters in his era he beat have a better resume at 168 than Canelo.

Not if he beats David Benavidez

[MikeyMike100]

The delusion of these Canelo stans.

I think you can count Plant & Benavidez as quality wins, but the rest of those are trash.

GGG beat him twice at 160 & Canelo finally legitimately beat him when he was 157 years old in a new weight class

The first 2 fights with GGG are irrelevant in this discussion. We are strictly talking about what hes done at a SMW