If Canelo Beats Beanvidez he's clearly the best 168 of all time

[MikeyMike100]

yea I don't get this claim

if Benavidez wins its elevates him massively into being a star but if Canelo wins ppl will say Benavidez was all hype

a win for nelo won't be worth much at all

Ya that's an unfair double standard

[hugh grant]

Benavides not best anyone, but he passed eye test.

[just the facts]

Benavides not best anyone, but he passed eye test.

Cmon now, I’ve been extremely critical of Benavides in the past but then he EASILY beat both Plant and Andrade. You can’t say that with a straight face.

[crimsonfalcon07]

We're not talking about head to head, we are talking about resume and accomplishments

If you don't think he could beat them in a head to head fight, how can he be the GOAT? If his skill level isn't there to beat them in a mythical matchup, then all his resume says is that he was fortunate to fight in a weak era. Head to head skills are absolutely relevant.

[hugh grant]

Cmon now, I’ve been extremely critical of Benavides in the past but then he EASILY beat both Plant and Andrade. You can’t say that with a straight face.

Yeh, I think benavides is good. I'm really addressing the people who think benavides doesnt deserve a fight as he's not best anyone or fought anyone great.? But even if that were true, he still passed eye test, so he deserves a fight on that basis alone.
I think hesca scary looking dude and it'd be great win

[MikeyMike100]

If you don't think he could beat them in a head to head fight, how can he be the GOAT? If his skill level isn't there to beat them in a mythical matchup, then all his resume says is that he was fortunate to fight in a weak era. Head to head skills are absolutely relevant.

Its like when people say Joe Louis is the goat heavyweight. Obviously, he wouldnt beat Tyson Fury or Lennox Lewis.

[crimsonfalcon07]

Its like when people say Joe Louis is the goat heavyweight. Obviously, he wouldnt beat Tyson Fury or Lennox Lewis.

Consider me unimpressed with Tyson Fury. Lennox Lewis would be a tougher out for Louis IMO. Usyk will be a good test for Fury, although he's no Rocky Marciano with freakish power for his size. But I think once you reach a certain weight, there's not as much advantage as you might think being heavier.

[just the facts]

Hahaajaj hello Noo Wards best win at 168 was a robbery plain n simple.

Trey Shaw, please explain how Ward beating Froch was a robbery.

[just the facts]

Hahaajaj hello Noo Wards best win at 168 was a robbery plain n simple.

Trey Shaw, still waiting for you to tell us how Ward beating Froch was a robbery. I know that fits your racist agenda but it ain’t true.

Every single post you make on this website is made with racist motives. No exceptions.

[QueensburyRules]

Its like when people say Joe Louis is the goat heavyweight. Obviously, he wouldnt beat Tyson Fury or Lennox Lewis.

- - Now, mikey, there U go again runnin' around leaking without your Barney BigBoys again. Need a new minder!!!