Inoue is P4P #1 at the moment

[The Big Dunn]

The fact remains that he's destroying everybody in his path on the way to the top. Whether you've heard of them or not isn't really his problem. They held belts. They were obviously somebody.

I have had this debate with alot of people.

Inoue and Crawford both have resumes that are undervalued and under appreciated.

Resumes should be judged by where the boxer was when they fought In real time, not based on where a guy is 2-3 years after that fight.

[IceTrayDaGang]

What does this have to do with Floyd or his fans? The majority of posters weighing in on this thread are not Floyd fans.

This is about Inoue being #1 p4p.

Which specific Floyd fans said this about Spence?

I ask because many other diehard Manny fans are saying the exact opposite. They are saying Bud was being criticized by “ Floyd fans” and Spence was being elevated.

"what does this have to do with floyd fans"... but you are on here talking about "pac fans ...."

[LeOoze]

I have had this debate with alot of people.

Inoue and Crawford both have resumes that are undervalued and under appreciated.

Resumes should be judged by where the boxer was when they fought In real time, not based on where a guy is 2-3 years after that fight.

I think Inoue has a better resume slightly in terms of competition, but Bud/Spence was a 50/50 fight. Most people had Inoue beating Fulton. So I give the nod to Bud.

But it does have an asterik for now because it seem Spence was damaged between all the car accidents and eye retina injury.

[The Big Dunn]

I think Inoue has a better resume slightly in terms of competition, but Bud/Spence was a 50/50 fight. Most people had Inoue beating Fulton. So I give the nod to Bud.

But it does have an asterik for now because it seem Spence was damaged between all the car accidents and eye retina injury.

Ok. I would disagree about Spence condition. I thought Fulton/inoue was 50/50 as well.

lol i was wrong on both accounts.

[Airtioteclint]

I think Inoue has a better resume slightly in terms of competition, but Bud/Spence was a 50/50 fight. Most people had Inoue beating Fulton. So I give the nod to Bud.

But it does have an asterik for now because it seem Spence was damaged between all the car accidents and eye retina injury.

That depends on who you ask. Because there were people on this very forum swearing up and down talking about how Inoue better stay at 118 because if he even try 122 Fulton would eat him alive.

Well he did exactly that. Now all of a sudden Fulton was a nobody.

[IronDanHamza]

Yeah, Inoue, Canelo, Usyk, Bivol. Top P4P.

I don't see how people have Crawford rated so high, he's 35 and finally beat someone worth a damn, but that someone was a guy that has alcohol issues, been in 2 major car accidents, one that almost killed him, detached retina, and is already slurring his words when he speaks. Eyeball test doe.

Probably because he's a 3 weight Lineal Champion, 2 of which undisputed champion.

I think that might be why.

[Airtioteclint]

They didn't hold belts tho. Just 2 bums he chose

He was undisputed at 118.

And if you want to pick at resumes I can do the same with bud too. But I don't that.

[LeOoze]

Ok. I would disagree about Spence condition. I thought Fulton/inoue was 50/50 as well.

lol i was wrong on both accounts.

Yeah I thought spence and Fulton were going to win. Or at the very least, be competitive fights. Even in hindsight, Inoue shouldn't have been a 4/1 favorite, but I guess that's more of a compliment to him.

I think Spence's condition is absolutely worth mentioning if we're going to rank Bud overall at least in terms of ATG's.

Spence is a good/great 147 lber, but with 2 car accidents, with 1 being life threatening. Multiple layoffs, AND a separate detached eye retina injury? I also think he looked drained. I can put Bud as #1 p4p, but overall Bud still falls very short to other boxers. I don't know if Bud could beat a prime Cotto.

[The Big Dunn]

"what does this have to do with floyd fans"... but you are on here talking about "pac fans ...."

I specifically stated Canelo and Manny fans in this thread. Not all.

Please read carefully.

Silence, El illegal racist, and hugh grant did exactly what I posted.

Again, don’t understand why you posted Floyd fans when none are really responding.

[Hustle]

He was undisputed at 118.

And if you want to pick at resumes I can do the same with bud too. But I don't that.

He wasn't undisputed when he fought Diapen and Dasmarinas.

You don't know that because you never even heard of them dudes and you never even knew he fought them dudes until i just told you.

So how you got a dude p4p number 1 and you don't even know who he been fighting...smh