PR vs Mex in Championship Fights: Who won?

[AintGottaClue]

Imo:

1. Sanchez
2. JC Chavez
3. Finito Lopez
4. Carlos Zarate
5. Oscar de la Hoya
6. Marco Antonio Barrera
6a. Eric Morales
8. Rubén Olivares
9. Miguel Canto
10(t). Lupe Pintor, Alfonso Zamora, Chiquita Gonzalez

"Mantequilla" Nápoles was Cuban by the way

well what about PR's list lol?

[morancito]

well what about PR's list lol?

Should be something like this. Ricans should have a better list though:

1. Wilfredo Gomez
2. Tito
3. Carlos Ortiz
4. Wilfred Benitez
5. Hector Camacho
6. Esteban de Jesus
7. Edwin Rosario
8. John Ruiz
9. Chegui Torres
10. Juan LaPorte

[IwatchBoxing]

Should be something like this. Ricans should have a better list though:
1. Wilfredo Gomez
2. Tito
3. Carlos Ortiz
4. Wilfred Benitez
5. Hector Camacho
6. Esteban de Jesus
7. Edwin Rosario
8. John Ruiz
9. Chegui Torres
10. Juan LaPorte

The real list:
Wilfredo "El Radar" Benitez (53-8-1, 31 KO's)
Felix "Tito" Trinidad (42-1, 35 KO's)
Wilfredo "Bazooka" Gomez (44-3-1, 42 KO's)
Carlos Ortiz (60-7-1, 29 KO's)
Edwin "El Chappo" Rosario (47 -6, 41 KO's)
Sammy "El Torbellino" Serrano (52-4-1, 17 KO's)
Jose "Chegui" Torres (41-3-1, 29 KO's)
Estaban De Jesus (57-5, 32 KO's)
John John Molina (52-7, 33 KO's)
Wilfredo "Pride of Puerto Rico" Vazquez (56-9-2, 41 KO's)

[morancito]

The real list:
Wilfredo "El Radar" Benitez (53-8-1, 31 KO's)
Felix "Tito" Trinidad (42-1, 35 KO's)
Wilfredo "Bazooka" Gomez (44-3-1, 42 KO's)
Carlos Ortiz (60-7-1, 29 KO's)
Edwin "El Chappo" Rosario (47 -6, 41 KO's)
Sammy "El Torbellino" Serrano (52-4-1, 17 KO's)
Jose "Chegui" Torres (41-3-1, 29 KO's)
Estaban De Jesus (57-5, 32 KO's)
John John Molina (52-7, 33 KO's)
Wilfredo "Pride of Puerto Rico" Vazquez (56-9-2, 41 KO's)

Your putting Benitez (and Tito) ahead of Gomez tells us everything we need to know about your total lack of boxing knowledge.

[m00ks]

LOL funniest thread. Show me a Puerto Rican who's gonna pick Mexico and a Mexican who will pick Puerto Rico. lmao

[IwatchBoxing]

Your putting Benitez (and Tito) ahead of Gomez tells us everything we need to know about your total lack of boxing knowledge.

Gomez isnt our #1, hes #3, get over it, you only want him at #1 cause you consider Sanchez your #1 and he beat him after he moved up in weight, here , your #1 is #1, for beating our #3, only thing wrong with the times list is Cotto I would think .

http://www.boxingtimes.com/specials/2005/top15pr_boxers.html

[Sir_Jose]

Gomez isnt our #1, hes #3, get over it, you only want him at #1 cause you consider Sanchez your #1 and he beat him after he moved up in weight, here , your #1 is #1, for beating our #3, only thing wrong with the times list is Cotto I would think .
http://www.boxingtimes.com/specials/...pr_boxers.html

Gomez is your #1 you dumb ****.

and Sal Sachez is not great because of 1 win. The guy also beat Azumah Nelson, Juan LaPorte and Little Red Lopez2x.

[morancito]

Gomez isnt our #1, hes #3, get over it, you only want him at #1 cause you consider Sanchez your #1 and he beat him after he moved up in weight, here , your #1 is #1, for beating our #3, only thing wrong with the times list is Cotto I would think .
http://www.boxingtimes.com/specials/...pr_boxers.html

OK dude, listen to me very carefully: Benitez had the talent to be the best, actually he had the talent to be one of the best p4p to ever live. But fact is, he never realized that talent. Fact is, his best accomplishment was to beat a natural lightweight at light middle in Roberto Duran. His other accomplishments were going the distance with Leonard and Hearns, both of whom beat him. Not only is Benitez NOT your all-time best, he doesn't even crack your top 3. Try and get over it.

Gomez was the best 122 pounder there ever was, hands down. Even demolished Mexican greats Carlos Zarate and Lupe Pintor, 4th and 10th on my list. He was a solid title holder at 126 and, to a much lesser extent, at 130. Gomez is head and shoulders above all other Puerto Rican fighters. I tell you again, it's not even close.

[IwatchBoxing]

OK dude, listen to me very carefully: Benitez had the talent to be the best, actually he had the talent to be one of the best p4p to ever live. But fact is, he never realized that talent. Fact is, his best accomplishment was to beat a natural lightweight at light middle in Roberto Duran. His other accomplishments were going the distance with Leonard and Hearns, both of whom beat him. Not only is Benitez NOT your all-time best, he doesn't even crack your top 3. Try and get over it.
Gomez was the best 122 pounder there ever was, hands down. Even demolished Mexican greats Carlos Zarate and Lupe Pintor, 4th and 10th on my list. He was a solid title holder at 126 and, to a much lesser extent, at 130. Gomez is head and shoulders above all other Puerto Rican fighters. I tell you again, it's not even close.

So lasting 15 RD's with two top five All- Time greats is nothing?And beating another top five All- Time Great, whos an all- time great for moving up in weight in the first place, is nothing?Plus we talking about heavier weights, where the biggest/best fighters are, oh and it can be argued he beat Hearns. if anything, Benitez is a top five all-time great too.

[Sir_Jose]

So lasting 15 RD's with two top five All- Time greats is nothing?And beating another top five All- Time Great, whos an all- time great for moving up in weight in the first place, is nothing?Plus we talking about heavier weights, where the biggest/best fighters are, oh and it can be argued he beat Hearns.

Shut up, Stop spewing bull****, Sit back and learn something from people who know more about this sport than you. Just because you read something on WilfredBenitez.com doesn't make it true.

No lasting 15 rounds doesn't mean **** if you LOSE. I dont get how you see he is so great because he LOST these fights?

What dont you get about Duran being an old man at 154? I mean seriously what dont you get, tell me what you dont get and I will explain to you. Everyone who knows anything about this sport knows Duran was at his best years earlier at 135.

Oh because he weighted more that means he's better? So are you gonna try and tell me John Ruiz is better than guys like Rafeal Marquez, Manny Pac or Kostya Tszyu. After all he is fighter at a heavier weight and thats where the better fighters are.