Comments Thread For: Canelo Loss Opens the Top Spot: BoxingScene P4P Update

[Liondw]

A nice topic to chat about, but is all opinion.

Pound for pound best of all, you could say Robinson, Leonard, Ali, Floyd, Armstrong, Louis or someone else. What does it matter, they were all great boxers.

[markusmod]

This list lost all credibility. Lmao @ Spence above Crawford

I know plenty of people that have Spence above Crawford based on their welterweight runs. Crawford's welterweight run has been terrible. Even Spence's blowout of Ocampo is gaining ground as Ocampo has become a bit of a beast since then.

[El_Mero]

usyk unified
crawford
spence unified
inoue unified
canelo undisputed
jermell undisputed
haney undisputed
stevenson unified
tank
taylor undisputed

i'm replacing taylor with beterbiev if he wins on saturday

fixed it for you

[HanzGruber]

Do people really have shakur in the top 10 lol

[rrayvez]

1- Naoya Inoue
2- Oleksandr Usyk
3- Canelo Alvarez
4- Terence Crawford
5- Juan Estrada

Canelo’s & Estrada way too high. One got beaten soundly in his last fight while the other has had 2 fights in 2 yrs with his last fight being a gift since he really lost.

[The Big Dunn]

I can’t see having Inoue #1 ahead of Usyk. Don’t agree Spence ahead of Crawford. Fury is too low. Charlo too high.

Was nice to see Fulton there but where is Navarette?

[IronDanHamza]

Do people really have shakur in the top 10 lol

Why not.....?

[richardt]

I can’t see having Inoue #1 ahead of Usyk. Don’t agree Spence ahead of Crawford. Fury is too low. Charlo too high.

Was nice to see Fulton there but where is Navarette?

Inoue's best are Rodriguez and an aged but good Donaire but no way should he be #1. But I'm glad my lobbying Boxing Scene for Charlo worked at least to get him into the top 10, but perhaps #7 is a little high - but damn, he doesn't marinate fights, he makes them happen, immediately, unlike a lot of champs. I also agree about Navarette who has gone through some really good opponents. Fulton also nice to see him there.

[IRONCHINHAGLER]

Glad to see Tank not on list… has the elite p4p skills but a resume full of cherries/mismatches. Scared to risk that 0.

[Nash out]

We all know that there is only one top 10 P4P list that matters, and that is in the Great Nash's sig. Nash out.