Comments Thread For: Canelo Loss Opens the Top Spot: BoxingScene P4P Update

[Get em up]

A nice topic to chat about, but is all opinion.

Pound for pound best of all, you could say Robinson, Leonard, Ali, Floyd, Armstrong, Louis or someone else. What does it matter, they were all great boxers.

This post is the correct way to look at it. P4P is subjective and opinionated at best

[Silence]

Canelo’s & Estrada way too high. One gotta beaten soundly in his last fight while the other has had 2 fights in 2 yrs with his last fight being a gift since he really lost.

Canelo lost the challenge not his belts. If he was American, he would still be #1.

Estrada still in top 5. Only Jermell Charlo has a case for #5. I'd rather Estrada.

[kingstip9]

The p4p list isn’t real and subjective anyway, so I guess it doesn’t really matter either way

[Luilun]

Funny how Spence is a career weight bully at 147 but is ranked above Canelo who has won 4 weight divisions to Spence 1 the list is trash Canelo should be 2 or 3 at best Spence should be 10

[ShoulderRoll]

Inoue passes the eye test but not the resume test.

Let's remember that he wasn't even in the top 10 of the last Competition Index.

[pretty boy_]

Great list. Swap out #4 for #10 and it’d be perfect. Crawford hasn’t done a damn thing in 5 years.

[NachoMan]

Tyson Fury and Dimitry Bivol are in the P4P? And where is the youngest 'Undisputed' lightweight champion of all time, Devin Haney?!

#1 on the P4P Most Boring LIst

[NachoMan]

Funny how Spence is a career weight bully at 147 but is ranked above Canelo who has won 4 weight divisions to Spence 1 the list is trash Canelo should be 2 or 3 at best Spence should be 10

I don't even care much for Spence, but he's an UNDEFEATED weight bully who has one of the better resumes in the sport at the moment (with no controversial wins either).

[rrayvez]

Canelo lost the challenge not his belts. If he was American, he would still be #1.

Estrada still in top 5. Only Jermell Charlo has a case for #5. I'd rather Estrada.

your implication that Canelo is at a disadvantage for being Mexican and not American is laughable. He’s literally the most entitled boxer ever and would likely have 4-5 losses if he were American. He’d also have a few less wbc titles too.

[HanzGruber]

Why not.....?

I haven’t done a pfp list in a long time but seems kind of premature