Am I off base?

[4truth]

First 4 rounds were reasonably close, either way.

Canelo then won the 9th but other than that I gave every other round to Bivol.

Exactly as all the judges scored the fight. You could certainly argue the first 3 rounds should not have been scored for Canelo by all 3 judges but those were close rounds and Canelo threw the harder stuff. When I see fights live, the harder punches make a greater impression, on me at least, than when I’m watching on a screen.

[just the facts]

Exactly as all the judges scored the fight. You could certainly argue the first 3 rounds should not have been scored for Canelo by all 3 judges but those were close rounds and Canelo threw the harder stuff. When I see fights live, the harder punches make a greater impression, on me at least, than when I’m watching on a screen.

No unbiased person (that obviously leaves you out) judging this fight could possibly see it 3-0 Canelo after 3rds. 4truth my asz.

[4truth]

No unbiased person (that obviously leaves you out) judging this fight could possibly see it 3-0 Canelo after 3rds. 4truth my asz.

Just stating the facts. I watched the fight at home and didn’t give the first 3 rounds to Canelo. All 3 judges, who were ringside did. This is truth.

[Smash]

So you scored it exactly one round differently than I did but you were compelled to post an ignorant comment? You’re a douche bag.

I didnt think it was an ignorant comment actually

[Smash]

Just stating the facts..

just stating the facts to just the facts, i like it

[eco1]

put it this way, u wont be offered a job as a boxing judge in vegas

Unless he becomes a crook. LOL.

[eco1]

i think i had nelo doing a lot better than that, i gave him 3 rounds

noooooo, maybe 2

[eco1]

First 4 rounds were reasonably close, either way.

Canelo then won the 9th but other than that I gave every other round to Bivol.

Canelo won the 9th, completely agree, but just because Bivol stepped of the gas for one round.
Canelo should NOT ask for a rematch cause he will be KO'd badly.

Bivol knows he can take all the uppercuts for ginger and laugh at them. He will not be that cautious in the next fight and will pick Canelo apart since the 1st round. By 9-10, Canelo will be sleeping.

[paulf]

I had it 9-3 and I try to score cards realistically.... as in the way I think they'll be judged. If I rewatched it I might have it 10-2 or 11-1 because the vast majority of punches Canelo landed hit gloves. The crowd screaming every time it happened had me going "Okay yeah, judges probably scored that for Canelo" even though it simply was not a landed punch.

[Nash out]

Legimate boxing expert, expert scorer LMAO! You're a flunky floozie with your arse hanging out.

Nash 'arsed' out lol.

You've got to respect the boxingscene hall of fame, War Room. We all must respect Nash. Nash is worthy of that. Nash out.