Better Win Amir Over Maidana OR Kell Over Porter

[BodyBagz]

Brook won clearly

I don’t think Amir did?

Khan vs Mai was a more entertaining fight.
That's about it.

[GrandpaBernard]

Khan vs Mai was a more entertaining fight.
That's about it.

I remember Amir doing great early on

then winning with a combination of flurries and running

both guys showed massive heart that night

Maidana to get up from that liver shot to fight strong to the end

[BodyBagz]

I remember Amir doing great early on

then winning with a combination of flurries and running

both guys showed massive heart that night

Maidana to get up from that liver shot to fight strong to the end

A favorite fight of mine.
Ortiz vs Khan should have happened
I would have favored Vic.

[HENNY]

Khan-Maidana was the better fight to watch imo

But, looking back in hindsight, Brooks win over Porter looks better on paper, and is better overall. Porter is a much more accomplished and better fighter than Maidana

[Haka]

Porter was a stiff bum without boxing skills, so I'd take Maidana as the lesser of 2 evils.

[Haka]

............<removed>

[KillaMane26]

Brook! Porter has fought everyone including Spence/Crawford. And nobody has ever beaten Porter like he did and to add to that Porter was closer to his prime.

Which brings me to the question.... When was Porter boxing prime ( not physical) ? Porter definitely improved skill wise after the fight. I'm leaning towards when he fought Thurman

[Rip Chudd]

Khan vs Maidana was more entertaining but Brook's win over Porter was better.

[aAgger]

Funny considering it was Amir who was fighting for his dear life and getting brutally battered the last half of the fight. He took more power punches in round 10 than Floyd did his entire career lol..

Khan was leading for most of the fight, up until round 10 when Maidana made a comeback. But after Khan survived round 10, he recovered and the last 2 rounds were close. But it was too late for Maidana, as Khan was wide ahead on the scorecards.

The first Mayweather-Maidana fight was very close. There were many who even thought Maidana was robbed. Either way, it was much closer than the Khan-Maidana fight. But Mayweather made the necessary adjustments and dominated his second Maidana fight.

[diplo]

Put it this way, I was shocked that Khan managed to beat Maidana with his chicken legs. Totally did not expect him to win, so by that measure, I guess Khan had a 'better' win. On the other hand, Brook beat a more accomplished Porter, but I never felt that Brook was going to get a beat down even if he lost.

So Brook had a more impressive win, Khan had a more surprising win.