Better Win Amir Over Maidana OR Kell Over Porter

[Flickergrab98]

I haven’t seen Brook’s fight against Porter, so I don’t know if it was a more dominant performance. But I can say that on a surface level Khan’s win was better since it had a bigger name.

[STREET CLEANER]

How do you fight Porter and NOT hold? The guy just runs in with his head down.

Well did well with the check hook when Porter came in. But he didn't stepped left or right which he can clearly do.

[PRINCEKOOL]

Amir Khan win over Maidana is better.

[Amir Imam]

Definitely Amir Khan vs. Marcos Maidana. That was the 2010 Fight of the Year. And then a few years later, Maidana went on to give Mayweather the fight of his life (since Castillo).

Funny considering it was Amir who was fighting for his dear life and getting brutally battered the last half of the fight. He took more power punches in round 10 than Floyd did his entire career lol..

[Earl-Hickey]

Khan's win over Maidana.

Seriously I was posting on here back then and for like 2 years straight almost everyone on here was saying Maidana would KO Khan with a jab, Khan would duck Maidana forever and never dare face him, Maidana would put Khan in a coffin etc, etc, etc.

Khan over Maidana was one of the most hilarious wins on here, haters got SO salty after GUARENTEEING Khan would A) never fight Maidana B) get ktfo by Maidana in 1 round if he ever did fight him.

[daggum]

Khan's win over Maidana.

Seriously I was posting on here back then and for like 2 years straight almost everyone on here was saying Maidana would KO Khan with a jab, Khan would duck Maidana forever and never dare face him, Maidana would put Khan in a coffin etc, etc, etc.

Khan over Maidana was one of the most hilarious wins on here, haters got SO salty after GUARENTEEING Khan would A) never fight Maidana B) get ktfo by Maidana in 1 round if he ever did fight him.

is porter not a much better fighter than maidana though? just because people thought he was ducking maidana(he was) doesnt mean its the better win. also when you look back at maidana's career at 140 he was a paper tiger, only stopping ortiz because of ortiz's anxiety and looking bad in his other notable fights, especially the fight before khan against corley. that was bad

[shenmue]

I was at the Maidana vs Ortiz fight, I've never heard such loud punches landed at a fight, from both men.

Ortiz got brutalized the last few rounds of that fight, he quit but watch that fight back, IT was only a matter of time before he got stopped by the ref.

Maidana and porter were both top 4 in their divisions when Khan and brook beat them, porter had a titie and was in good form and maidana looked a nightmare fight on paper for Khan, both good wins for different reasons.

[Loque-san]

I say Khan over Maidana looks better, not because I think Maidana is better than Porter or anything, but because that fight was far more entertaining; Khan showed amazing heart and he actually fought a clean fight. Porter-Brook was an ugly affair with Brook clinching non stop.

[BodyBagz]

Porter was more accomplished

[GrandpaBernard]

Brook won clearly

I don’t think Amir did?