Has Manny surpassed Tito on the ATG list?

[them_apples]

Hell no.

Oscar was ****ed, Hatton was always a tool how do they compare to Oscar when he was undefeated and Vargas who too was undefeated.

because even taking away those 2 wins he has a better resume then tito

[We want Floyd]

I can't believe none of y'all have mentioned Tito Trinidad beating the great Pernell Whitaker. That's f**kin' huge, although Sweet Pea was past prime, but that version of Pea would've still given alot of cats all kinds problems and a solid chance of beaten 'em too.






Anyway, PAC over Tito on the ATG list.

[JAB5239]

Pacquiao is already higher than Tito on the ATG list IMO.

I think so too.

[hugh grant]

Dont mention tito in the same sentence as Pac. Not in the same class as pac.
The only tito people know are michael jacksons brother. Thats who tito is isnt he?

[-EX-]

He's definently higher than Trinidad...

[Spray_resistant]

I would rank Pac above Tito, already he has better wins against more top fighters in different weight classes. Still Tito was entertaining and made for great fights. Wins over Fargas, Whitaker, Reed, Mayorga, and especially how he destroyed Joppy in his first MW fight against a champion none the less. I can't overstate what a great win that was, the best of his career in my view.

[-EX-]

It may be close but I'd go with Pac like I said before...

Trinidad's strongest wins are over Camacho, past prime Whitaker, and DLH

Pacquiao: Barrera, Marquez, Morales(you can dispute if that was Morales at his best in the 2nd and 3rd fights)

Tito does have Oba Carr and Vargas as well...

I could see someone still going with Trinidad...I may give an edge to Pac cuz of the going up in weight business

[switch44]

No doubt about it kid.

[bojangles1987]

Absolutely. Trinidad was very good but hasn't beaten anything close to the competition Pac has.

[wXh]

umm...Tito isnt an ATG