Real robberies of recent years

[blowblow]

Pac/Marquez 3 is the only strong case. Everything else was a close fight.





I'm disappointed that NONE of you called out Barrios/Akmehdov, if we're talking judges, or Hererra/Hinojosa, if we're talking outcomes.

bradley 1 the strongest.

[Combat Talk Radio]

7-5? Lol you need to watch that fight again Pac clearly won 9-10 rounds. He literally out landded him every round and more then twice overall but ok

"AT THE END OF THE DAY", what did the scorecards say?

[Combat Talk Radio]

True. It all depends on what a person thinks of as a "robbery".
I think of a robbery as a decision that takes away a legitimate win from a fighter.
Of course a "legitimate" win is in the eye of the beholder.

How do you define "legitimate"?

Anyone who thinks Manny was "robbed" against Bradley is basing "legitmate" on Compubox.

Ok, so then by that logic, Keef was robbed by Manny. Right?

[GhostofDempsey]

PAC vs JMM 1, Bradley 1, and Horn

Oscar vs Floyd, Trinidad and Mosley

Maidana vs Floyd 1

Lara and Trout vs Canelo

Castillo 1 vs Floyd

GGG vs Canelo - both

Kovalev vs Ward I

[clmags12]

One of the recent ones was Charlo/Castano. Imo mell got worked, wasn't a draw

[ruedboy]

How do you define "legitimate"?

Anyone who thinks Manny was "robbed" against Bradley is basing "legitmate" on Compubox.

Ok, so then by that logic, Keef was robbed by Manny. Right?

A legitimate win is one where one fighter clearly wins more rounds.
I think Pac clearly beat Bradley, so I'd call that a robbery.
The Thurman fight was closer but I think the judges got it right.
Also CompuBox is a joke.

[-Kev-]

PAC vs JMM 1, Bradley 1, and Horn

Oscar vs Floyd, Trinidad and Mosley

Maidana vs Floyd 1

Lara and Trout vs Canelo

Castillo 1 vs Floyd

GGG vs Canelo - both

Kovalev vs Ward I

Interesting.

You forgot GGG vs Derevyanchenko and Jacobs.

[Combat Talk Radio]

A legitimate win is one where one fighter clearly wins more rounds.

Again, define "clearly". Clearly to WHO?

Pac/Bradley. Three judges had it a close fight.

You can't sit up here and say "well I didn't see it close so they robbed him".

Because again, by that logic, Keef beat Manny and got robbed. Right?

[Combat Talk Radio]

PAC vs JMM 1, Bradley 1, and Horn

Oscar vs Floyd, Trinidad and Mosley

Maidana vs Floyd 1

Lara and Trout vs Canelo

Castillo 1 vs Floyd

GGG vs Canelo - both

Kovalev vs Ward I

None of them robberies EXCEPT MAYBE Kov/Ward 1.


And I've yet to have any of you justify why these close fights are robberies but Herrera/Hinojosa wasn't.

[QueensburyRules]

Herrera vs Danny Garcia

- -Poor Dannyboy and Pappy humiliated on their homecoming...only in boxing, folks...