Announcement

Collapse
No announcement yet.

How strong is todays WW era?

Collapse
  • Filter
  • Time
  • Show
Clear All
new posts

  • How strong is todays WW era?

    First of all do you think that perhaps Crawford and Spence are both a bit of the ole eyetest? For me they're maybe just that touch above say an Ugas, a Porter I wouldn't even say a level or a cut above. They're just that little fraction better.

    I'm not mentioning Manny because its a given he has great success in any era and holds his own when compared to anyone and Floyds long retired so lets exclude them both please.

    Spence, Porter, Ugas, Crawford, whoever else you want to throw in from WW -
    How would they compare to lets just say that mid 80s American boxer-puncher era that was full of very tall, rangy, hard hitting and extremely fundamentally sound WWs? They wasn't these 5'6 & a whisker WWs with 69" reaches these were a good 5'10 and fought like it.
    Just extremely well schooled basics. Beautiful crisp punches that looked effortless, sharpness which I really do not see today, much at all actually.


    I am talking guys like Mark Breland, Donald Curry, Marlon Starling, Milton McCrory throw in a few underrated Brits from this era in Colin Jones and Lloyd Honeyghan
    Maybe also Simon Brown and whoever I've missed.

    How would they fare in this horribly underrated era largely ruled with this classic American style?

    Does Spence compete with guys who are just as big and have better fundamentals than himself? Can Porter have decent success or would it be Porter vs Brook 2 all over again? What about Crawford and the likes?

  • #2
    I want to include Vergil Ortiz as I think a lot of those fights would have been fun but its anyones guess really just how good he is or isn't at this stage but feel free to include him and give your thoughts on why or why he wouldn't do well

    Comment


    • #3
      A 42 yr old natural featherweight is one of the best in the division and might just beat 2 of top 3 ww in the division after aug 21
      El_Mero El_Mero likes this.

      Comment


      • #4
        Honestly not strong at all and that could even include Spence and Crawford

        You only have to go back 10 to 15 years and see the top 10 was a tough road if you wanted to be number 1

        Floyd Mayweather, Jr
        Shane Mosley
        Miguel Cotto
        Paul Williams
        Antonio Margarito
        Oscar de la Hoya
        Pacquiao

        Throw in fringe contenders like clottey and even some top 135/140 fighters who could compete like JMM and Ricky Hatton

        Comment


        • #5
          Originally posted by davef View Post
          Honestly not strong at all and that could even include Spence and Crawford

          You only have to go back 10 to 15 years and see the top 10 was a tough road if you wanted to be number 1

          Floyd Mayweather, Jr
          Shane Mosley
          Miguel Cotto
          Paul Williams
          Antonio Margarito
          Oscar de la Hoya
          Pacquiao

          Throw in fringe contenders like clottey and even some top 135/140 fighters who could compete like JMM and Ricky Hatton
          Clottey from back then would give all these guys a hard time tbh.

          imagine what guys like tito would do against them. Imagine Ray or hearns? Murder.

          Comment


          • #6
            Originally posted by davef View Post
            Honestly not strong at all and that could even include Spence and Crawford

            You only have to go back 10 to 15 years and see the top 10 was a tough road if you wanted to be number 1

            Floyd Mayweather, Jr
            Shane Mosley
            Miguel Cotto
            Paul Williams
            Antonio Margarito
            Oscar de la Hoya
            Pacquiao

            Throw in fringe contenders like clottey and even some top 135/140 fighters who could compete like JMM and Ricky Hatton
            I'd take prime zab judah over all these 140 and 147 guys tbh.

            Comment


            • #7
              Mark Breland! He didn't do a thing of note as a pro. Beat nobody I couldn't fold in half in two minutes. He is not a disloyal trainer who spikes water, but he was also not a great professional boxer. Again, old-school bias as always. The old guard is held to lower standards. Guys today aren't allowed to lose. Nash out.

              Comment


              • #8
                Spence is legit.

                He gives anyone a tough night

                Comment


                • #9
                  In terms of achievements: Spence is Quartey level. Crawford is kinda Mosley level. Thurman is Corrales level. If you can't see it, then you're a casual.

                  They definitely could compete in the 2000s.

                  Comment


                  • #10
                    Originally posted by RGJTMMRDCMJRJSM View Post
                    In terms of achievements: Spence is Quartey level. Crawford is kinda Mosley level. Thurman is Corrales level. If you can't see it, then you're a casual.

                    They definitely could compete in the 2000s.
                    Crawford is nowhere near Mosley level. When has he ever beaten a prime Oscar level opponent?

                    Comment

                    Working...
                    X
                    TOP