Who does better against Roy Jones at 154lb: Floyd or Manny?

[Stuntman Mike]

Neither, both are most effective once they are in the inside but I should remind myself that smaller men are faster. If I had to pick one it would be Floyd.

Floyd isn't going to throw enough punches ,he will be completely defensive and any pot shots will be taken like they're nothing to Roy

Manny on the other hand would throw combinations and get the crowd excited by landing decent straight body shots but would be payed back with powerful shots like he's never had before

Manny would get tkod or kod at anytime but I would give a guess at round 4,5 or 6

Mayweather would survive until the 10th I'd guess but inflicting zero damage he'd get broken down on the complete defensive with several knockdowns mainly due to the power of Roy's shots and balance(could see roy knocking Floyd down even if the shots are blocked) prior to the ref waving it off

[Stuntman Mike]

Floyd

manny gets knocked out in the quickness

What does Floyd do exactly? Manny would try and Floyd would get ragdolled whilst been completely defensive not even trying to score punches

If you gage that on who would do better I'd prefer it if I got to chose an Olympic limbo dancer/runner

Manny may get knocked out quicker but hed do more damage and Floyd would not survive the 12 rounds defensive or not so the answer to "who would do better?" Would be manny for me


Who would last longer? Floyd
Who would be more competitive? Manny

[MONGOOSE66]

Floyd isn't going to throw enough punches ,he will be completely defensive and any pot shots will be taken like they're nothing to Roy

Manny on the other hand would throw combinations and get the crowd excited by landing decent straight body shots but would be payed back with powerful shots like he's never had before

Manny would get tkod or kod at anytime but I would give a guess at round 4,5 or 6

Mayweather would survive until the 10th I'd guess but inflicting zero damage he'd get broken down on the complete defensive with several knockdowns mainly due to the power of Roy's shots and balance(could see roy knocking Floyd down even if the shots are blocked) prior to the ref waving it off

It’s hard to say cause of the size difference and it’s a FACT. Small men are much faster but they don’t hit as hard to get the respect from Jones. Kinda of a silly comparison.

[Stuntman Mike]

It’s hard to say cause of the size difference and it’s a FACT. Small men are much faster but they don’t hit as hard to get the respect from Jones. Kinda of a silly comparison.

Problem is Jones was just as fast as either man in his prime regardless of size

Jones would smoke both of them one after the other in his prime

I believe pacquiao would do better

I believe mayweather wouldnt even mount up points because the first time he opens up he gets hurt a lot more than maidana mosley or pacquiao hurt him and his head shaking won't work on Jones he will find openings easy and land bombs

When mayweather shells up after been hurt he just absorbs body shots really well from whoever has attacked his body

when Jones is breaking virgill Hills ribs with a right hand mayweather wont last long in that shell up

[MONGOOSE66]

Problem is Jones was just as fast as either man in his prime regardless of size

Jones would smoke both of them one after the other in his prime

I believe pacquiao would do better

I believe mayweather wouldnt even mount up points because the first time he opens up he gets hurt a lot more than maidana mosley or pacquiao hurt him and his head shaking won't work on Jones he will find openings easy and land bombs

That’s easy to say. No proof.

[Stuntman Mike]

That’s easy to say. No proof.

Of course no proof it's a debate about a fantasy fight and its my opinion if you dont know the rules then why are you in here haha

[Stuntman Mike]

That’s easy to say. No proof.

Please tell me your opinion on this fantasy fight..do you believe floyd pot shots his way to a decision over a prime Roy Jones?

Or does Floyd do to Roy what he did to gatti and corales?

[Amir Imam]

Pacquiao got bullied all over the ring by a substitute teacher Jeff Horn. Come on! We’re talking about a guy who needed a trilogy with Gim Bradley. Roy finishes him inside 2

[HrNY]

Pacquiao who fought fishnets, using that same game plan, against a bigger, but drained Roy at 154, maybe Roy becomes yet another black fighter(Clottey, Mosely, Mayweather, Broner, Tim 1) that runs away from a Filipino midget

[HrNY]

Please tell me your opinion on this fantasy fight..do you believe floyd pot shots his way to a decision over a prime Roy Jones?

Or does Floyd do to Roy what he did to gatti and corales?

Floyd got countered clean by f'in mcgregor because of his reach, what more with Jones.

Floyd fought Shane and Zab who's reach pretty much matched his, and Floyd actually took a good hit from both guys. Both guys couldn't keep it up, but Roy could/would.