Worse score cards in recent memory?

Collapse
Collapse
  • Time
  • Show
Clear All
new posts
  • Shadoww702
    Banned
    Franchise Champion - 20,000+ posts
    • Sep 2015
    • 41176
    • 4,546
    • 2,938
    • 250,035

    #21
    Originally posted by kushking

    Your cards are just as awful. fury didn't beat Wilder by 6 pts,(2 kds means Wilder only won 2 rds on your card) GTFO,Ggg didn't beat Canelo by 4 Pts GTFO,Loma/Lopez wasn't a Draw GTFO, ironically you scored for Castano by 2 pts despite ggg/Canelo being a way more even fight,yet you got ggg by 4,no wonder you are a Ufc fan,that trash sport makes you crazy

    Its always funny when ppl cry robbery but have awful cards
    Yeah
    that 4 rounds for Canelo tells me he bent way the *** over for ggg in close rounds. Personally I gave it 7-5 ggg but a draw was fair and 1 round was a coin flip I just happened to give to ggg. But I wasn't like ggg WON that round...

    If I remember he scored the 2nd fight the same way. Which TELLS me it's not even about the styles??? Because if you like puncher then you got ggg won the 1st and Canelo 2nd. If you like boxers then it's Canelo 1 and ggg 2.

    He looked a GGG's dic the entire fight since his scorecard was already filled out! Both times.

    Comment

    • eco1
      Undisputed Champion
      Unified Champion - 10,00-20,000 posts
      • Nov 2015
      • 10086
      • 1,759
      • 8,642
      • 71,221

      #22
      GGG Canelo 1 and 2. Golovkin won both fights.
      Krusher-Ward 1, disgusting to see what happened there, Kovalev won that one.

      Comment

      • Shadoww702
        Banned
        Franchise Champion - 20,000+ posts
        • Sep 2015
        • 41176
        • 4,546
        • 2,938
        • 250,035

        #23
        Originally posted by The Big Dunn

        Yeah that card was bad as was the open scoring in the Canelo/Trout fight that had Trout down so much.

        Respect your opinion but disagree strongly. While you and other solid posters scored it a draw, I felt after the 10th Charlo needed a ko to win.

        Now I didn’t consider a 10-8 round but I didn’t think charlo earned a 10-8 round myself.
        Open scoring is fine if the other guy wants to actually win. No Heart Trout KNEW he needed a ko but was dropped and bambi-legged a few more times so pulled a Callum Smith just wanting the fight to end and then he can blame someone else.

        Name one elite boxer who if they KNEW the scorecard and was down they just continue to run on 4th and Long??? 7 cant! And Victor Ortiz isn't elite. Him and Trout have have same size heart...

        Comment

        • Toyman
          Undisputed Champion
          Platinum Champion - 1,000-5,000 posts
          • Sep 2011
          • 1022
          • 148
          • 59
          • 7,174

          #24
          Manny vs Floyd scorecards were all wrong. Floyd was out landed both in terms of quantity and quality. Should have been a win for Manny - draw at the very worst if you give Floyd every close round.

          Spoons thread details this very well. Round 3,4,6,7,10,12 - those are 6 rounds that I cannot possibly see how anyone scored for Floyd. The other 6 rounds were mostly debatable. Floyd only won 1 or 2 rounds clearly.

          Other bad decisions were Kovalev vs ward and ggg vs canelo.

          Comment

          • Spray_resistant
            Vacant interim regular(C)
            Franchise Champion - 20,000+ posts
            • Feb 2009
            • 29620
            • 2,978
            • 1,566
            • 53,384

            #25
            Tavoris Cloud on Showtime getting a decision over Gabriel Campillo is one of the worst robberies I have ever seen.

            Comment

            • IronDanHamza
              BoxingScene Icon
              Franchise Champion - 20,000+ posts
              • Oct 2009
              • 49455
              • 5,022
              • 269
              • 104,043

              #26
              Originally posted by Toyman
              Manny vs Floyd scorecards were all wrong. Floyd was out landed both in terms of quantity and quality. Should have been a win for Manny - draw at the very worst if you give Floyd every close round.

              Spoons thread details this very well. Round 3,4,6,7,10,12 - those are 6 rounds that I cannot possibly see how anyone scored for Floyd. The other 6 rounds were mostly debatable. Floyd only won 1 or 2 rounds clearly.

              Other bad decisions were Kovalev vs ward and ggg vs canelo.
              I can’t possibly see it either.

              Makes you wonder how 100% of press row scored it for Floyd.

              Comment

              • IronDanHamza
                BoxingScene Icon
                Franchise Champion - 20,000+ posts
                • Oct 2009
                • 49455
                • 5,022
                • 269
                • 104,043

                #27
                Rios-Abril
                Casamayor-Santa Cruz

                In recent times (last 20 years) are two of the worst.

                If we talk all time then Whitaker-Ramirez and Harold Johnson-Willie Pastrano are the two worst I’ve seen.

                Comment

                • R-Hand Southpaw
                  Undisputed Champion
                  Platinum Champion - 1,000-5,000 posts
                  • Dec 2017
                  • 2342
                  • 199
                  • 32
                  • 58,647

                  #28
                  Originally posted by The Big Dunn

                  I think we need to be honest that Ward is employed by TR and there is clearly a conflict of interest there. His card and yours are extreme outliers.

                  I look at Ward’s card the way I did the draws given to Wilder ( fury)and Charlo ( castano)- draws where the network preferred guy actually lost and was given a draw.

                  The overwhelming majority of media, fans , judges and anyone else that watched the fight scored it for lopez.

                  Given that Loma didn’t start punching until round 8 and clearly lost round 12, I think 8-4 is reasonable. I don’t see how you can give Loma rounds 2 and 7.
                  Im reading right now what a majority of people are saying online and the scores exist between 8-4 and a draw so I don't understand how usually can claim a majority of people scores the fight for Lopez. You literally have no metric for that. This is not quite like Canelo/GGG where score cards were posted galore and have GGG winning 90% and 70% respectively and being unable to win.

                  Also, I'm not arguing the result but the blateny corruption which is funny because Ward, Teofimo, Lomachenko are all paid by ESPN so where is your conflict of interest?

                  Was the location and judges not also paid by ESPN?

                  So you literally have no argument. I could argue that Bob wanted the torched passed to a younger more marketable prospect which is why the cards were so rigged in his favor and what would you say?

                  Nothing.

                  Because that makes a hell lot more sense than what you're saying.

                  117-111 and 119-109 are bigger outliers than a scorecard that said DRAW.

                  Feel free the do some mental gymnastics telling me that Lomachenko is the networks preferred guy at 32 years old and not some 23 year old kid. Come on. At PBC you guys do this thing all the time.

                  Teofimo is Latino, American, has a big mouth and is much younger than Lomachenko. He is the preferred guy. When Taylor moves up who do you think TR will feature at 140? You talk smart all the time but why you got to act so dumb?

                  Comment

                  • R-Hand Southpaw
                    Undisputed Champion
                    Platinum Champion - 1,000-5,000 posts
                    • Dec 2017
                    • 2342
                    • 199
                    • 32
                    • 58,647

                    #29
                    Originally posted by kushking

                    Your cards are just as awful. fury didn't beat Wilder by 6 pts,(2 kds means Wilder only won 2 rds on your card) GTFO,Ggg didn't beat Canelo by 4 Pts GTFO,Loma/Lopez wasn't a Draw GTFO, ironically you scored for Castano by 2 pts despite ggg/Canelo being a way more even fight,yet you got ggg by 4,no wonder you are a Ufc fan,that trash sport makes you crazy

                    Its always funny when ppl cry robbery but have awful cards
                    I'm a fan if a lot of combat sports and I'm not ashamed of that. You act like just because someone can like another combat sport that isn't boxing it makes them less of a fan but that's not true is it?

                    I feel sorry for someone like you who lives in their own delusion believing boxing is the end all. You're like a mentally challenged person telling me that because I have a college degree I'm ******. Who's the ****** one?

                    Guys like you can't even understand your own sport so it makes perfect sense for you to pretend you do and others don't. I'm a BOXING FAN, I'm SO SMART. LMFAO.

                    Imagine. I could watch any MMA or kick boxing fight and know exactly what each fighter is going for and attempting to do.

                    You on the other hand? No ****ing idea. All you would say is look, sweaty guys laying on each other and KICKS! You're the ****** one and you're so proud of that.

                    LMFAO.

                    GGG/Canelo 1 was not close at all. How's a fight close when 90% of the people who saw it saw GGG win? Do I need to post the link to this very own site proving that?

                    Do i need to post all the media cards that had GGG winning?

                    Let me guess. You wanna defend yourself with the opinion of people who didn't score the fight on paper but only watched it for entertainment? Lmfao. You guys already did that. Try something new.

                    like here's a little revisit from the guys at DAZN. Dudes you used to suck as hard as you do any Mexican fighter.



                    The scores the saw on review are

                    115-113
                    115-113
                    116-112

                    Oh! But I'm so out of touch lmfao.

                    Comment

                    • R-Hand Southpaw
                      Undisputed Champion
                      Platinum Champion - 1,000-5,000 posts
                      • Dec 2017
                      • 2342
                      • 199
                      • 32
                      • 58,647

                      #30
                      Originally posted by Shadoww702

                      Yeah
                      that 4 rounds for Canelo tells me he bent way the *** over for ggg in close rounds. Personally I gave it 7-5 ggg but a draw was fair and 1 round was a coin flip I just happened to give to ggg. But I wasn't like ggg WON that round...

                      If I remember he scored the 2nd fight the same way. Which TELLS me it's not even about the styles??? Because if you like puncher then you got ggg won the 1st and Canelo 2nd. If you like boxers then it's Canelo 1 and ggg 2.

                      He looked a GGG's dic the entire fight since his scorecard was already filled out! Both times.
                      Well, unlike you guys I was watching the fight and not Canelos **** like so many of you Mexicans do.

                      Our score card literally differed by one point but NO. There's no way he could have given Canelo only 4 rounds when you literally only gave him 5.

                      I think 7-5GGG would have been fair but it was NOT a draw. You guys have had 4 years lie to yourselves and create new lies for you to believe. It's so funny to see!

                      I scored the first fight 8-4 GGG and the second fight 7-5 GGG. 7-5 and a draw respectively would have been acceptable. Canelo did not win either fight. No one believes he did and this can be proved by the large influx of score cards that exist.


                      Comment

                      Working...
                      TOP