Canelo or Inoue, who ranks higher P4P?

[Fists_of_Fury]

Talking about PEDs while having Gayweather on your avatar?

Mayweather never popped for performance enhancing drugs, Canelo did though

[El_Maldito_Rey]

If only Canela hadn't lost to Mayweather in a very embarrassing fashion, I would rate them both equal.

One loss at an early age to the P4P #1 guy vs 6 losses to a couple of nobodies.

Donaire vs GGG in a P4P fight? Both same weight, height, etc. Donaire gets flattened harder and faster than the Walters fight.

[El_Maldito_Rey]

Mayweather never popped for performance enhancing drugs, Canelo did though

Nah Gayweather knew how to mask them with those illegal IVs. Plus he had the NSAC in his back pocket.

[Fists_of_Fury]

Nah Gayweather knew how to mask them with those illegal IVs. Plus he had the NSAC in his back pocket.

Clenelo tried to mask his performance enhancing drug use with a Mexican meat excuse. He still got suspended and will always be known as an official performance enhancing drug cheater. Clenelo has more gifts and is more suspect of having commissions in his back pocket than any fighter I have ever heard of. There will always be an asterisk beside Clenelo's name because he is a drug cheat.

[Skillz12]

I think we can all agree Mayweather was on the juice and he did try to hide them With his IV excuse but like the little spoiled ***** that he is he cried until to let him get away with it.

[El_Maldito_Rey]

Clenelo tried to mask his performance enhancing drug use with a Mexican meat excuse. He still got suspended and will always be known as an official performance enhancing drug cheater. Clenelo has more gifts and is more suspect of having commissions in his back pocket than any fighter I have ever heard of. There will always be an asterisk beside Clenelo's name because he is a drug cheat.

Well I guess he didn't mask them as well as Gayweather did for his entire career.

Want to bring up gifts? Gayweather has plenty. Plus all the disadvantages he gave boxers, like making Maidana wear pillow gloves.

Gayweather has plenty of asterisks. Plus he's a closet h0mo, but that's besides the point.

[Skillz12]

Gayweather shouLd easily be 47-3

lost to Castillo’s as a clear as day.
lost To Oscar arguably
lost Maidana the first fight clearly.

[El_Maldito_Rey]

I think we can all agree Mayweather was on the juice and he did try to hide them With his IV excuse but like the little spoiled ***** that he is he cried until to let him get away with it.

Gayweather did everything possible to cheat his way to wins.

Weight disadvantages
Picking the gloves
Picking and paying off refs and judges
masking PEDs
Never fighting outside of Las Vegas
plenty of losses that his judges ruled in his favor

He was a farce.

[El_Maldito_Rey]

Gayweather shouLd easily be 47-3

lost to Castillo’s as a clear as day.
lost To Oscar arguably
lost Maidana the first fight clearly.

The Judah fight should've been a DQ loss when the uncle stormed the ring.

[-Kev-]

Top 10 P4P lists usually, but not always, consists of undefeated fighters who look great against weak opposition. Hence, Crawford is there. But some boxers who look good, or just manage to win against good opposition are sometimes left out. Or put on the lower part of the list. It’s a bit of unfair list to be honest.

It is safe to say that Canelo looks good/gets wins over top opposition. Really the best opponents he can fight, he fought, and beat. He has more of those wins than Inoue.

Inoue has also fought very good opposition, the best he can fight, and looked good beating them. The only time he had a tough fight was really vs Donaire, a future HOFer, and he won.

My point is, no matter who you think actually belongs at number 1, it’s undeniable that both are top 2. They earned their spot.