Canelo or Inoue, who ranks higher P4P?

[El_Maldito_Rey]

Rigo is an ATG, no shame in losing to Rigo, hell Donaire even scored a knockdown. Frampton was a featherweight.

Is he though?

Doniare got flattened by a part time boxer in Walters. Walters for sure isn't an ATG. Probably wouldn't make it into the HOF.

Magdaleno plus others are the rest of his losses.

He's nowhere near on GGG's level.

[Fists_of_Fury]

Canelo is ranked higher if you don't penalize him for being a PED cheat. Inoue if you want only clean boxers in your P4P list.

[Fists_of_Fury]

Lol. Overrated ass Donaire got his ass beat by Frampton got embarrassed by Rigo and has numerous other losses. He's not worthy of tying Canelo's laces.

And Inoue struggled with his ass.

ATG? Lol! Dumbass casuals.

Donaire is a clean boxer, Canelo is a PED cheat.

[pacphobia]

Lol. Overrated ass Donaire got his ass beat by Frampton got embarrassed by Rigo and has numerous other losses. He's not worthy of tying Canelo's laces.

And Inoue struggled with his ass.

ATG? Lol! Dumbass casuals.

If only Canela hadn't lost to Mayweather in a very embarrassing fashion, I would rate them both equal.

[Fists_of_Fury]

Is he though?

Doniare got flattened by a part time boxer in Walters. Walters for sure isn't an ATG. Probably wouldn't make it into the HOF.

Magdaleno plus others are the rest of his losses.

He's nowhere near on GGG's level.

Donaire's overall resume > GGG. GGG is one of the biggest hype job cherry pickers in boxing history. And Clenelo struggled with him the 1st fight but his paid off judges gifted him a draw. He beat the Mexican style out of Borat the 2nd fight though, after popping for performance enhancing drugs.

[Blond Beast]

Lol. Inoue, who edged past the shell of Nonito Donaire, three years after Donaire was schooled by Carl Frampton! Inoue is not in my top 50. Canelo is 2 P4P behind the great Tyson Fury.

I’m with you with Tyson being one of the most overrated boxers ever. Still a huge fan, and he was a great attraction. But his skills are more myth than reality. I could go on.

As far as Inoue I really like his stuff. Its hard for me to call him overrated on the same level as I just don’t hear enough brag about him or lofty comparisons against other fighters. He’s also in a lower weight which is less recognized, and most would have a hard time even mentioning his peers throughout history. I love the all action style of Japanese fighters, their heart, their chins, but usually they lack power and defence. Inoue brings power and a level of skill far beyond most Japanese fighters. His win vs Donaire though not easy looks good with Donaire’s latest ko win. But I can’t see how he could ever be above Canelo. If anyone is wanting to learn to box, Canelo is the style all kids should try to emulate and pull off if capable. He throws 90mph fast balls all night. He slips punches. He ****s a guys sides until they flinch right into uppercuts.

[icha]

Donaire is easily much, much better than GGG. It's not even close.

ggg was top 3 p4p when canelo fought him, donaire not even top 20 when he fought inoue...
prime donaire was a different story...

[pacphobia]

Donaire is a clean boxer, Canelo is a PED cheat.

Exactly. You can't rank a PED CHEAT higher to a CLEAN atg fighter in Donaire. A PED CHEAT will always be a PED CHEAT and he will be remembered as a PED CHEAT forever.

[El_Maldito_Rey]

Exactly. You can't rank a PED CHEAT higher to a CLEAN atg fighter in Donaire. A PED CHEAT will always be a PED CHEAT and he will be remembered as a PED CHEAT forever.

This guy talking about PEDs while having Pacquiao plastered all over his avatar and sig? Lol. Ok.

[El_Maldito_Rey]

Donaire is a clean boxer, Canelo is a PED cheat.

Talking about PEDs while having Gayweather on your avatar?