PBF or Pac? Whos Resume is Better?

[strugler]

We were discussing something else...and Manny did more impressively against a weight drained fighter who hadn't fought at 147 in 8 years...

and PAC never fought at ww ever..........LOL.........ODH had NAcho + dundee etc.................

[-EX-]

well if you say the opposition he has faced........im down with you..........but if you take into account their performance..........you got to hand it to JMM................

Isn't that we were talking about?

"ricky hatton is the toughest/hardest fight of my career" floyd mayweather


/thread

Floyd said Augustus gave him the toughest fight of his career...

[-EX-]

and PAC never fought at ww ever..........LOL.........ODH had NAcho + dundee etc.................

Now you sound like a Pac nuthugger...why are you bringin up trainers?

Pac never fought at WW which is why I give him some credit for beating DLH

[strugler]

Isn't that we were talking about?



Floyd said Augustus gave him the toughest fight of his career...

well i take into account how they perform......dont you?............if you dont.................my bad.
OSCAR:
TITO, BHOP, PAC, JCC, PEA, IKE,PBF, etc
JMM:
PAC,MAB, PBF

[-EX-]

well i take into account how they perform......dont you?............if you dont.................my bad.
OSCAR:
TITO, BHOP, PAC, JCC, PEA, IKE,PBF, etc
JMM:
PAC,MAB, PBF

I take into account the wins first and foremost...Cotto looked good against Margarito but who won?

[strugler]

Now you sound like a Pac nuthugger...why are you bringin up trainers?

Pac never fought at WW which is why I give him some credit for beating DLH

NOw youre talking like a hater.............PACS fault was he made it look too easy...lol.........and Oscar wasnt prime, wasnt of old...........but i doubt anyone can do what PAC did that night................

[Walt Liquor]

We were discussing something else...and Manny did more impressively against a weight drainedfighter who hadn't fought at 147 in 8 years...

well, that's still more impressive, considering where manny came from than the horrible pitty pat, no action, snoozefest that floyd put on. That was a horriffic fight. At least manny went out there and beat that ass. Floyd could have made oscar look old like manny did.

[-EX-]

NOw youre talking like a hater.............PACS fault was he made it look too easy...lol.........and Oscar wasnt prime, wasnt of old...........but i doubt anyone can do what PAC did that night................

He made it look too easy? I've only brought up facts...the man was past his prime, weight drained, and hadn't fought at 147 in 8 years...

Any top welterweight wudda beat Oscar that night...you can't be serious

[strugler]

I take into account the wins first and foremost...Cotto looked good against Margarito but who won?

JMM hasnt been dominated ...............he has a close loss and draw against PAC............Oscar was given a gift against sturm......struggled with a past prime pernell...........didnt rematch ike or tito.........was beaten into quittage by a former flyweight............

[lee majors]

Prime undefeated Corrales(Who Floyd was underdog against), Castillo>Barrera, Morales, Marquez

Undefeated Hatton and 154lb DLH >Hatton, 147lb DLH(2 years after Matweather was done with both)

Gatti=Shot Morales(2nd fight)

Judah>More than half of Pacquiaos resume

Hernandez, Emmanuel Burton, Genaro, Baldomir>N/A

It's just that simple. There never was any confusion as to who was the better fighter and had the better resume while both were active. Now, after a 2 hiatus, people are discrediting Floyd's legacy, stating that Manny is the best fighter of this era. Meanwhile, Floyd went undefeated for 10 yrs fighting championship fights, 12 rounders. Floyd was the man before most folks knew what a Manny Pacquiao was. Floyd could fight Kelly Pavlik, toe to toe, for the MW title and still would get snubbed by this crowd. Floyd's skill is a curse it seems. Fights that were 'tooth and nail' for Manny would get diagnosed and solved by the 4 round, if Floyd were the participant. Then as a result of the ease of the fight, it wouldn't be deemed a classic like Manny's fights are viewed. Just imagine if Floyd had been fighting Erik Morales instead of Zahir Raheem. Only classic mentioned would be a classic asswhooping Floyd would have put on him.