PBF or Pac? Whos Resume is Better?

[Walt Liquor]

It's not really close at al. Manny has more wins vs pfp's, hof'ers at their weight at or near their primes.
Floyd's best win is Corrales or Castillo, manny's is morales, barrera, jmm. No contest.

[-EX-]

but point is he choked.................together with the sturm, ike, pernell arguments...................

Point is...

DLH- Vargas/Whitaker/Quartey

While Marquez's best win may be a old Casamayor...

[MaD RoBoT]

so are we comparin Pac's opponents resume against Floyd's opps resume now?

[Walt Liquor]

To the OP, you can't make a thread like this on BScene expecting to get a fair decision. This is like Malignaggi trying to get a decision in ouston....vs Diaz. Scorecard of 118-110 was BS just like the poll numbers are BS. This is Pacland over here. And if they are not Pacquiao fans then they are Mayweather haters.
Hernandez, Corrales, Castillo, Judah, 154lb DLH, Baldomir(who came in with a 8-year winning streak and Lineal Title), those guys alone are better than Pacquiao's whole resume.

This is a ridiculous post. There is no other way
to say it. How many hof boxers are on this list that are not on manny's resume? Lol at you defending the Baldomir and Judah wins.

[strugler]

Point is...

DLH- Vargas/Whitaker/Quartey

While Marquez's best win may be a old Casamayor...

whitaker past prime yet close...................Quartey very close too but i had oscar winning.......................Marquez best win arguably juan diaz, old casamayor, past prime barrera, and two very close fight with pac.............Marquez hasnt been dominated like BHOPS

[Walt Liquor]

Point is...

DLH- Vargas/Whitaker/Quartey

While Marquez's best win may be a old Casamayor...

Why argue about dlh anyway? They both beat a way over the hill delahoya and manny did much more impressively.

[-EX-]

whitaker past prime yet close...................Quartey very close too but i had oscar winning.......................Marquez best win arguably juan diaz, old casamayor, past prime barrera, and two very close fight with pac.............Marquez hasnt been dominated like BHOPS

Pernell was past his prime but still better than Diaz and Casamayor...

And Marquez didn't face a prime Barrera...

And 2 close fights are not wins....

De La Hoya's resume is clearly better

[-EX-]

Why argue about dlh anyway? They both beat a way over the hill delahoya and manny did much more impressively.

We were discussing something else...and Manny did more impressively against a weight drained fighter who hadn't fought at 147 in 8 years...

[strugler]

Pernell was past his prime but still better than Diaz and Casamayor...

And Marquez didn't face a prime Barrera...

And 2 close fights are not wins....

De La Hoya's resume is clearly better

well if you say the opposition he has faced........im down with you..........but if you take into account their performance..........you got to hand it to JMM................

[nujabes77]

"ricky hatton is the toughest/hardest fight of my career" floyd mayweather


/thread