PBF or Pac? Whos Resume is Better?

[-EX-]

cmon man, it's not impressive that floyd put on a garbage fight against an old ass delahoya who was coming off getting his ass beat by sturm and crushed by my boy bhop and looked like crap against forbes. Neither win v dela really impresses me, but I give manny slightly more credit cuz he was a huge underdog and he went out there and beat that ass like floyd shoulda done.

Yet you choose to ignore the fact that one fight was at 147 and the other was at 154...

And I'd take Freddie Roach over Angelo Dundee and Nacho at this point...

Dundee aint Dundee from the 70's and 80's...

[Walt Liquor]

I don't find it too impressive he beat a shell of DLH...if Pac beats Cotto I will be impressed and convinced he can hang at 147...

Anyone with eyes can see Floyd fought a better DLH than Pacquiao did...

Also, if manny beats cotto, he will already have beaten a bigger threat than floyd ever did at floyd's weight. And that is pathetic considering how long he's been a ww. Sad, floyd's resume at 140 and up is really just sad.

[-EX-]

how about which version of hatton was better?.................lol

I give both guys full credit for beating Hatton...

[-EX-]

Also, if manny beats cotto, he will already have beaten a bigger threat than floyd ever did at floyd's weight. And that is pathetic considering how long he's been a ww. Sad, floyd's resume at 140 and up is really just sad.

Floyd annhilated a champ at 140 and beat the best at 130 and 135...

Pac didn't do **** at 135...

[strugler]

I give both guys full credit for beating Hatton...

fair enough.............

[-EX-]

theyre relevant...............he left no stones unturned...........he hired the best................he prepared to the fullest..................only to quit against a former flyweight................

Dundee is not the best these days... What has he done lately?

And bringing up the flyweight discussion is ******...well DLH was a former super featherweight...

[strugler]

Dundee is not the best these days... What has he done lately?

And bringing up the flyweight discussion is ******...well DLH was a former super featherweight...

ok...a former lightweight who jumped 2 divisions......arguably 3.............to make his ass quit..........

[Walt Liquor]

Yet you choose to ignore the fact that one fight was at 147 and the other was at 154...

And I'd take Freddie Roach over Angelo Dundee and Nacho at this point...

Dundee aint Dundee from the 70's and 80's...

I ignore it cuz of how far manny was coming up. I could argue all day about how many times floyd uses weight to his advantage. Oscar wanted to come down. For the reasons I said in my above post I think manny's win was superior. And you ignore my points as well. Iat least I am being objective I'm that oscar was over the hill and neither win is really that great, manny put it on him and floyd fought a lame ass scared fight when he probably coups have stopped oscar. Therefore manny's win better. What was floyd scared of? Oscar couldn't even stun Steve forbes

[-EX-]

ok...a former lightweight who jumped 2 divisions......arguably 3.............to make his ass quit..........

That's ******ed...in that case...


Oscar is a former super featherweight who beat Vargas...

Bringing up that is pointless...

[Leakbeak]

Mayweather's resume is much better but people won't give him credit for it because he made it look easy. Pac has been outboxed by Morales and has questionable win's and draws V Marquez. I don't think Floyd would has any such woes on his resume. He has had better opposition that Pacman because he has beaten more fighters in their primes. Most of Pacman's victories were V fighters slightly past their best of even over the hill. And yes, his claim to fame is Floyd's leftovers! I'm not a big big Floyd fan before anyone comes up with such silly accusations. It is just a fact that he has fought better giys on top of their game from 130 to 154 and he didn't make them come down in weight all the time! If he can fight Oscar at 147 then why not Cotto at the same weight? Why does he always have to make his opponents dehydrate so he can have a chance? Oscar was dumb for rehydrating after the HBO weigh in