PBF or Pac? Whos Resume is Better?

[-EX-]

Right, he doesn't devour his opponent. Remind me when floyd went up 3 weight classes in 2 fights? I can't remember.

I'm not saying floyd should have kod oscar, but there is no way that fight should have been competitive, therfore lame performance by floyd. That does not make me look ******.

David Diaz and a weight drained DLH...how impressive

And why should the fight not have been competitive? DLH chose the ring the gloves, the weight and he forced Floyd to move up...

[-EX-]

Mayweather- Castillo, Corrales, Hatton, Judah, old DLH, G. Hernandez

Pacquiao- Barrera, old Morales, Marquez, Hatton, weight drained old DLH, Larios

I don't see how Pac's resume is WAYYYY past Floyd's...

[strugler]

You have yet to proven that point...and the manner of victory comes second

barrera X2, mORALES x3, jmm X2, hatton, Cotto, Delahoya..........pac
CASTILLO X2, hERNANDEZ, HATTON, Oscar,JMM....................PBF

[Blue Heffner]

They're about the same, not that much different. But when it's all said and done, it'll be Mayweather. He going to fight and beat Marquez, Pacquiao, and Cotto for sure.

[Walt Liquor]

I put David Diaz and Baldomir in the same boat...neither guy aint special...

Floyd already beat Hatton...both guys got wins over him...

And we'll see how Pac looks against Cotto...but I think he'll win...

I'll take the fact that you have ignored my point about cotto (if manny wins) being a better win than floyd has at 147 than floyd has and how pathetic that is.

Also, by your own logic regarding weights, is it not more imressive to come up 2 divisions (in 2 fights) to beat the recognized champion, than it is to make the same champion come to a weight where he already looked ordinary.

Look ex, it doesn't give you less of a chance at nuthugger of the year to admit some faults in floyd. Good lord. I mean you self own constantly and are making these ridiculous points like defending floyd's resume at 140 blindly. I can admit when my favorite fighters do ***** ****- like when bhop fought oscar and didn't fight with enough heart v Taylor. I have a laundry list of things that I wish my favorites had done (another example is pwill not immediately signing to beat clottey's ass now he has no fight), but I am still a fan.

[strugler]

Mayweather- Castillo, Corrales, Hatton, Judah, old DLH, G. Hernandez

Pacquiao- Barrera, old Morales, Marquez, Hatton, weight drained old DLH, Larios

I don't see how Pac's resume is WAYYYY past Floyd's...

if youre gonna bring Corales and judah...........ledwaba,sasakul, larios,

[MOTHER DUCKER]

Mayweather- Castillo, Corrales, Hatton, Judah, old DLH, G. Hernandez

Pacquiao- Barrera, old Morales, Marquez, Hatton, weight drained old DLH, Larios

I don't see how Pac's resume is WAYYYY past Floyd's...

Pretty much its not.. IMO pacs first destruction of Barrera was his most impressive win ever. Got to remeber Pac also lost to a declining Morales too and his win over Marquez is disputed but over the 2 fights, Marquez won more rounds easily too.

However i think Pac really won the 2nd fight though as a knockdown should have been counted when Marquez fell back and only stay up by grabbing the ropes. The point is though that even tho he beat Marquez and knocked him down 4 times he was completely outboxed, something that never happened to Floyd.

I can buy Pacs resume being slightly ahead of Floyd's but way ahead thats just some plain nuthugging bull **** right there..

[-EX-]

barrera X2, mORALES x3, jmm X2, hatton, Cotto, Delahoya..........pac
CASTILLO X2, hERNANDEZ, HATTON, Oscar,JMM....................PBF

I'm guessing you saying he beat the guy twice makes the resume better?

So if I beat a guy more than once it makes it even better? :lol:

[-EX-]

Pretty much its not.. IMO pacs first destruction of Barrera was his most impressive win ever. Got to remeber Pac also lost to a declining Morales too and his win over Marquez is disputed but over the 2 fights, Marquez won more rounds easily too.

However i think Pac really won the 2nd fight though as a knockdown should have been counted when Marquez fell back and only stay up by grabbing the ropes. The point is though that even tho he beat Marquez and knocked him down 4 times he was completely outboxed, something that never happened to Floyd.

I can buy Pacs resume being slightly ahead of Floyd's but way ahead thats just some plain nuthugging bull **** right there..

Pretty much how I feel at this point...

[-EX-]

I'll take the fact that you have ignored my point about cotto (if manny wins) being a better win than floyd has at 147 than floyd has and how pathetic that is.

Also, by your own logic regarding weights, is it not more imressive to come up 2 divisions (in 2 fights) to beat the recognized champion, than it is to make the same champion come to a weight where he already looked ordinary.

Look ex, it doesn't give you less of a chance at nuthugger of the year to admit some faults in floyd. Good lord. I mean you self own constantly and are making these ridiculous points like defending floyd's resume at 140 blindly. I can admit when my favorite fighters do ***** ****- like when bhop fought oscar and didn't fight with enough heart v Taylor. I have a laundry list of things that I wish my favorites had done (another example is pwill not immediately signing to beat clottey's ass now he has no fight), but I am still a fan.

I guess we'll just ignore the 8 YEARS in between...

And did u miss the part where I said Pac had the better resume?

And what exactly is wrong with his resume at 140? Hatton didn't want it at 140 and Arum himself said Cotto wasn't ready...who was he supposed to fight?