Since Margarito cheated..Do you still consider Cotto's record Undefeated?

[Johnny Rebel]

I'm a Cotto fan but Margarito's win over Cotto is legit but no doubt tarnished. It's still a loss for Cotto unfortunately. I think Cotto punched himself out by loading up on way to many punches and forgetting to pace himself which was foolish when you're fighting a fighter that's known for having a great chin and that's why he lost. Even without the plaster of Paris in his gloves, Tony would've won that night, IMHO.

[..WaRSpencE..]

if cotto is a mexican, to some mexican hes still undefeated
if cotto is a pinoy, to some pinoy hes still undefeated

BINGO!!!!

as for me..I guess I just see a (*) next to his 1L..Cuz officially he lost..but with all the circumstances..I have a feeling that wasn't a first offense..so the possibility is clearly there..

but until we hear some sort of confession..that 1L remains..no matter how much we speculate..

[Shattered Jaw]

I hate Margarito for cheating. He is a disgrace to the sport. Such talent wasted on cheating - SICKENING.

[Piolo Pascual]

i say he still has a loss.... nobody can prove beyond doubt that he cheated on teh cotto fight.

[MindBat]

you have a point.........how about a rematch?

This will help vindicate Cotto's loss if he wins, but won't change the first outcome results.

Public opinion and speculation can't change the record books.

If they fight and Margo wins the rematch, then Margo had his number long ago.

[fdotorres]

He got his ass kicked. End of Thread.

cintron whooped perro's ass without plaster, yet angulo made excuses and cotto didn't lol

[Mr. Fantastic]

cintron whooped perro's ass without plaster, yet angulo made excuses and cotto didn't lol

Then why was Cotto crying on how his face was swollen for weeks??

[MindBat]

... I think Cotto punched himself out by loading up on way to many punches and forgetting to pace himself which was foolish when you're fighting a fighter that's known for having a great chin and that's why he lost. Even without the plaster of Paris in his gloves, Tony would've won that night, IMHO.

Margarito was a punching machine that night who walked through Cotto's punches like he was sleep walking.

Cotto could've handled himself better, but he was in survival mode for the fight of his life.

[fdotorres]

Then why was Cotto crying on how his face was swollen for weeks??

same reason why margarito is crying over his ban

[Joe2608]

Margarito tried to cheat in the Mosley match, there's no proof that he cheated before that.