Would CALZAGHE be TOP 10 ATG if he would be AMERICAN? POLL

[Deja_Vous]

Clottey had the IBF. ANOTHER MAJOR BELT.

Name Calzaghes first 5 defenses and well name Berto first Defenses and see who's defenses are better.

Ahhhh ****..lol.

[dde91]

Joe managed to beat Joe Cortez and Bhop ofc he should be atg.

Also Roy jones actual resume ain't great but what he did was atg worthy, reigning supreme at smw for 10 years or so, while not as noteworthy as what roy did is atg status for me anyway bottom end top 50 or so..

Ofc if he was American this would be beyond doubt, im ****ing amazed at how they hype fighters like Pavlik/Lacy (that last one worked out well!) ill be back in a minute from some about lacy pre joe

Lacy was HOPED to be the next big thing. It happens to fighters all the time. Look at Ortiz right now. He was said to be the NEXT DE LA HOYA, but got his **** rocked recently. We found out Lacy was ****, end of that.

[Dirk Diggler UK]

Clottey had the IBF. ANOTHER MAJOR BELT.

Name Calzaghes first 5 defenses and well name Berto first Defenses and see who's defenses are better.

The IBF stripped Clottey because he wouldnt fight Issac Hlyatswaoo instead of Miguel Cotto.

Wow......what a fine upstanding organisation they are.

[MOTHER DUCKER]

Lacy was HOPED to be the next big thing. It happens to fighters all the time. Look at Ortiz right now. He was said to be the NEXT DE LA HOYA, but got his **** rocked recently. We found out Lacy was ****, end of that.

At first glance, I figured a match between he and Mikkel Kessler was compelling......but not after I saw what he did to pemberton tonight.

I realize Pemberton might not be in the same leauge as Kessler.....but simply being a tall rangy super middleweight will not cut it against Lacy.

If they fought, I think it would be one sided.

I initially said Lacy would pound out a decision win over Kessler....but now I think he will simply knock him out in the early rounds.

Along with Calzaghe.

Joe stands virtually no chance against this monster.

In fact, I think everyone short of Cruiserweight would lose.

Tarver, Johnson, Hopkins, Taylor,

all of them. Forgettaboutit. I'm not kidding either.

LOL and yet this win by Joe is shat on by Yanks haha, surely joe deserves atg status for his brutal 12/12 round win vs Jeff " the monster" lacy?

[dde91]

Im not jocking anyone. Im just laughing at this argument that somehow the colour of a belt matters....

If a belt doesn't matter, then Pacquaio to defend the IBO belt 10 times against mediocre or less then average competition, because Belts dont matter, right??? and it will look great on his resume right??

[DonTaseMeBrah]

do you have an excuse for the other 8 i mentioned?

those are good wins. but just pointing out that no great fighter's resume is perfect. it can be dissected & scrutinized like i just did. he lost to prime roy jones jr. & to calzaghe.

no fighter's resume is perfect.

Especially those that are undefeated. those are the worst ones....

[hammerhiem]

Someone care to comment on my post above^^^

Did you actually just name the resume of two people almost everyone has in teh top 20-40 ATG and say someone sucks because his resume doesn't match it?



Seriously?

err Calzaghe's resume is worse than Hopkins and RJJ (though alot of RJJ's resume fcuking sucks but strangly he catches no heat but hey hum) and err well Pacmans, probably Mayweathers and thets about it in his era he must really suck.... 5th in his era what a coward and fraud...

:gay:

[TredKiller]

LOL and yet this win by Joe is shat on by Yanks haha, surely joe deserves atg status for his brutal 12/12 round win vs Jeff " the monster" lacy?

lacy hits hard,

thats his skills.

lol

[Deja_Vous]

Lacy was HOPED to be the next big thing. It happens to fighters all the time. Look at Ortiz right now. He was said to be the NEXT DE LA HOYA, but got his **** rocked recently. We found out Lacy was ****, end of that.

We found-out Lacy wasn't **** when he barely got by Omar Sheika.

[dde91]

The IBF stripped Clottey because he wouldnt fight Issac Hlyatswaoo instead of Miguel Cotto.

Wow......what a fine upstanding organisation they are.

When you have a Belt, you are suppose to fight the NUMBER one contenders. If you didn't know. You cant just get a belt and call the shots. your an idiot if you think that.