Would CALZAGHE be TOP 10 ATG if he would be AMERICAN? POLL

[Dirk Diggler UK]

Wearing a WBC belt will ensure that you will have to fight better comp than the WBO.

Yes because Juan Urango is a better welterweight than Joshua Clottey of course.

[TredKiller]

Bhop resume:

Joe lipsey 25-0 (never fought again)
John David Jackson 35-2
Glen Johnson 32-0
Simon Brown 47-6
Antwun Echols 22-2 (22 ko's)
Keith Holmes 36-2
Felix Trinidad 40-0 (33 ko's)
William Joppy 34-2
Oscar De La Hoya 37-3
Howard Eastman 40-1
Antonio tarver, at LHW
Ronald Wright 51-3
Kelly pavlik 34-0 (30ko's)

RJJ resume:

Bernard Hopkins
James Toney
Vinny Pazienza
Mike McCallum
Montell Griffin
Virgil hill
Reggie Johnson
Richard Hall
Eric harding
Julio Cesar Gonzalez 27-0
Glen Kelly 28-0
Clinton Woods
John ruiz, HW title

Calzaghe's resume:

Chris Eubank
Mario Veit
Jeff Lacy
Mikkel Kessler
Past it Bhop
Shot Rj

campare?

Someone care to comment on my post above^^^

[dde91]

Bhop resume:

Joe lipsey 25-0 (never fought again)
John David Jackson 35-2
Glen Johnson 32-0
Simon Brown 47-6
Antwun Echols 22-2 (22 ko's)
Keith Holmes 36-2
Felix Trinidad 40-0 (33 ko's)
William Joppy 34-2
Oscar De La Hoya 37-3
Howard Eastman 40-1
Antonio tarver, at LHW
Ronald Wright 51-3
Kelly pavlik 34-0 (30ko's)

RJJ resume:

Bernard Hopkins
James Toney
Vinny Pazienza
Mike McCallum
Montell Griffin
Virgil hill
Reggie Johnson
Richard Hall
Eric harding
Julio Cesar Gonzalez 27-0
Glen Kelly 28-0
Clinton Woods
John ruiz, HW title

Calzaghe's resume:

Chris Eubank
Mario Veit
Jeff Lacy
Mikkel Kessler
Past it Bhop
Shot Rj

campare?

i hate RJJ too, and his Resume makes Calzaghe look like a School yard *****. Great Post!

[DonTaseMeBrah]

Bhop resume:

Joe lipsey 25-0 (never fought again)
John David Jackson 35-2
Glen Johnson 32-0
Simon Brown 47-6
Antwun Echols 22-2 (22 ko's)
Keith Holmes 36-2
Felix Trinidad 40-0 (33 ko's)
William Joppy 34-2
Oscar De La Hoya 37-3
Howard Eastman 40-1
Antonio tarver, at LHW
Ronald Wright 51-3
Kelly pavlik 34-0 (30ko's)

felix trinidad blown up welterweight moved up

oscar de la hoya blown up welterweight moved up

winky wright blown up junior middleweight moved up

kelly pavlik middleweight moved up at a catch weight of 170 (not a great fighter)

antonio tarver (not a great fighter) moved down from heavyweight for rocky film.

talk about catch weight bul****...

[Deja_Vous]

Yes because Juan Urango is a better welterweight than Joshua Clottey of course.

Berto won't be holding that belt very long.

It's Floyd's vacated belt...he didn't take it off anybody.


Brits have such a rich boxing heritage...why jock a fighter like Sloppy Joe??

It can't be that bad.

[MOTHER DUCKER]

Joe managed to beat Joe Cortez and Bhop ofc he should be atg.

Also Roy jones actual resume ain't great but what he did was atg worthy, reigning supreme at smw for 10 years or so, while not as noteworthy as what roy did is atg status for me anyway bottom end top 50 or so..

Ofc if he was American this would be beyond doubt, im ****ing amazed at how they hype fighters like Pavlik/Lacy (that last one worked out well!) ill be back in a minute from some about lacy pre joe

[dde91]

Yes because Juan Urango is a better welterweight than Joshua Clottey of course.

Clottey had the IBF. ANOTHER MAJOR BELT.

Name Calzaghes first 5 defenses and well name Berto first Defenses and see who's defenses are better.

[Deja_Vous]

Someone care to comment on my post above^^^

They can't...You're just a biased Yank.

[TredKiller]

felix trinidad blown up welterweight moved up

oscar de la hoya blown up welterweight moved up

winky wright blown up junior middleweight moved up

kelly pavlik middleweight moved up at a catch weight of 170 (not a great fighter)

antonio tarver (not a great fighter) moved down from heavyweight for rocky film.

talk about catch weight bul****...

do you have an excuse for the other 8 i mentioned?

[Dirk Diggler UK]

Berto won't be holding that belt very long.

It's Floyd's vacated belt...he didn't take it off anybody.


Brits have such a rich boxing heritage...why jock a fighter like Sloppy Joe??

It can't be that bad.

Im not jocking anyone. Im just laughing at this argument that somehow the colour of a belt matters....