Would CALZAGHE be TOP 10 ATG if he would be AMERICAN? POLL

[Dirk Diggler UK]

We found-out Lacy wasn't **** when he barely got by Omar Sheika.

But Joe was scared of Glen Johnson who lost to Omar Sheika

[Ray Ray]

felix trinidad blown up welterweight moved up

oscar de la hoya blown up welterweight moved up

winky wright blown up junior middleweight moved up

kelly pavlik middleweight moved up at a catch weight of 170 (not a great fighter)

antonio tarver (not a great fighter) moved down from heavyweight for rocky film.

talk about catch weight bul****...

Look at this hater here...

Trinadad...Did something Hopkins couldnt do (KO Joppy) He was a legit MW then and didnt hear anybody saying he's a blown up WW then...all of a sudden when Hopkins beats Tito...He's a blown up MW...If thats the case why was Tito the favorite in this fight??? Lets cut the bull****...you cant have it both ways

Oscar...Oscar made a name for himself at MW...so how can anyone deny he's a good fighter at MW...Lets not forget that Oscar was up on the scorecards before he got KO with that body shot.

Winky Wright...At the time he was top ten P4P and he put up a good fight.

Kelly Pavlik...Many thought Pavlik was going to ice the " Old Benard Hopkins" and we all saw what happened in that fight...If thats the case why was he the favorite of the fight if he didnt have a chance as you're trying to imply?

Anotonio Tarver...he was the lineal champion of the LHW division...anyone that says that this isnt a good win for Hopkins is a pure hater and doesnt have the slightest clue to what their talking about.

Overall...you post FAILS!

[TredKiller]

those are good wins. but just pointing out that no great fighter's resume is perfect. it can be dissected & scrutinized like i just did. he lost to prime roy jones jr. & to calzaghe.

no fighter's resume is perfect.

Especially those that are undefeated. those are the worst ones....

yea lol, like joe

Did you actually just name the resume of two people almost everyone has in teh top 20-40 ATG and say someone sucks because his resume doesn't match it?



Seriously?

err Calzaghe's resume is worse than Hopkins and RJJ (though alot of RJJ's resume fcuking sucks but strangly he catches no heat but hey hum) and err well Pacmans, probably Mayweathers and thets about it in his era he must really suck.... 5th in his era what a coward and fraud...

:gay:

i never said he was a fruad, but some people are trying to say cal has the better resume, read the thread befor you post, and the TS said cal is a top 10 ATG lmfao!

[Dirk Diggler UK]

When you have a Belt, you are suppose to fight the NUMBER one contenders. If you didn't know. You cant just get a belt and call the shots. your an idiot if you think that.

So Clottey vs Hylatswaoo was better because it was for the IBF belt. Whereas Clottey vs Cotto was **** because it was for the WBO.

Gotcha

[Deja_Vous]

But Joe was scared of Glen Johnson who lost to Omar Sheika

Johnson KO'd a fresher RJJ and didnt even have to get off the floor to do it.

[LA BAD BOY]

But Joe was scared of Glen Johnson who lost to Omar Sheika

Last time i checked JOE smashed SHEIKA and whats the point fight
Glen Johnson then?

[Dirk Diggler UK]

Johnson KO'd a fresher RJJ and didnt even have to get off the floor to do it.

What does that have to do with him losing to Omar Sheika? Apparently Lacy wasnt **** cos he struggled with Sheika, so what does that make someone who lost to him?

Does Lacy become a great fighter if he KOs RJJ in their fight?

[MOTHER DUCKER]

Johnson KO'd a fresher RJJ and didnt even have to get off the floor to do it.

Hatton KO castillo in 4 !! Mayweather couldn't do it in 24 rounds= hatton better than Floyd?? your dumb

[LA BAD BOY]

lacy hits hard,

thats his skills.

lol

CALZAGHE said he cant punch ****!

[dde91]

So Clottey vs Hylatswaoo was better because it was for the IBF belt. Whereas Clottey vs Cotto was **** because it was for the WBO.

Gotcha

Thats not what im saying. But Clottey and Cotto is was more then the WBO because it was to see who is number 2 in WW. I bet they dont even give a **** about the WBO. Cotto just lost his title from margarito a year before and Clottey is the real IBF champ. Cotto winning made him Number 2 WW, and possibly number one since he already beat shane. Cotto WBO defense against Clottey ****s on Calzaghes WHOLE WBO TITLE RUN.