was tarver tip top or weight drained against BHop

[bojangles1987]

NO ONE is allowed to make a weight drained excuse for this fight for Tarver after all the crap Tarver gave Roy Jones, who had to come down from near 200 pounds after winning a HEAVYWEIGHT CHAMPIONSHIP to BEAT Tarver. Tarver came down from 200 pounds after filming a f*****g movie, and got destroyed. No matter what condition he was in Tarver would get owned every time by Bernard Hopkins.

[Benncollinsaad]

If you really believe Hopkins won against a tip top shape Tarver then you must be crazy! How can people even deny this, only nuthuggers can.

[Spray_resistant]

He may have been weight drained, but it is his own fault and not Hopkins responsibility to make sure Tarver doesn't blowup in between fights. I hate that same excuse to marginalize someones victory that ppl use with the Jones/Toney fight all of the time on here. It is not like in either of these cases the weight drained fighters in question were moving down from where they normally fight, it was a career defining win for B-hop.