Gatti vs Cotto

[JACK D. RIPPER]

Prime for prime. Cotto by k.o in a ****in AT classic.

Cotto vs. Old Gatti (post Ward 1)....Cotto by Alfonso Gomez like demolition.

[Cleto_Reyes]

Gatti would tko Cotto inside of 9 rounds

[F l i c k e r]

A prime Gatti would beat Cotto. Because a prime Gatti went through hell for a living, going through 7 rounds of hell and then winning is Gatti's forte'. Cotto only fights 7 rounds and then gasses/runs.

Out of prime Gatti loses to Cotto no matter what.

[P4PKING_2008 :)]

Gatti stops him inside 2.

[Scott9945]

No it wasn't but Cotto didn't always fight at 147

So what? Everybody knows that a 140 lb Cotto tears up Gatti like a paper doll.

[F l i c k e r]

So what? Everybody knows that a 140 lb Cotto tears up Gatti like a paper doll.

Not a prime Gatti. Gatti in his prime takes more damage than Margarito and still pressures. Cotto would become discouraged and end up losing because Gatti doesn't pitty pat and isn't feather fisted either.

[Shadow boxer 3]

if this is a prime gatti we're talkin about, then this would be a good fight. cotto wins though

[catalinul]

Man I love Arturo and he's my all time great fighter but I don't see him ever beating Cotto at 140 or 147.

You gotta remember prime Gatti was at 130 and 135.

[Scott9945]

Not a prime Gatti. Gatti in his prime takes more damage than Margarito and still pressures. Cotto would become discouraged and end up losing because Gatti doesn't pitty pat and isn't feather fisted either.

So then tell me who the best fighter that "prime Gatti" ever beat was? Certainly nobody compared to Randall Bailey, Ricardo Torres, etc. Cotto's wins are miles better.

[Shadow boxer 3]

So what? Everybody knows that a 140 lb Cotto tears up Gatti like a paper doll.

a PRIME gatti gives cotto all he can handle. cotto would still get the win but it wouldnt be a walk in the park