Mayweather vs. Cotto. In July. Who do you think would win?

[Kevin Jesus]

Miguel Cotto's last 3 fights

Alfonso Gomez W
Antonio Margarito L
Michael Jennings W

Floyd Mayweather's last 3 fights

Ricky Hatton (Undefeated) W
Oscar De La Hoya (#1 JMW at the time) W
Carlos Baldomir (#1 WW at the time) W

Battling Nelson, my friend, what has Cotto done to prove himself as a top WW?

[HK45]

I bet they do

You thought that Cotto vs Mosley was razor thin and now Floyd blew Oscar out. Floyd vs Oscar was much closer than Cotto vs Mosley. I think your bias is starting to show.

[-Lowkey-]

Haha. I immediately discard "those people".

well i thought floyd did enough to win the fight but it wasnt exactly decisive by any means

[THE REED]

You thought that Cotto vs Mosley was razor thin and now Floyd blew Oscar out. Floyd vs Oscar was much closer than Cotto vs Mosley. I think your bias is starting to show.

I had Cotto beating Mosley.. CLOSE, but CLEAR.. and I said exactly that.

Just like I have Floyd beating Oscar by CLOSe and CLEAR UD.

I have no Floyd BIAS at all... go over to the thread where were talking abotu Floyd calling hismelf the greatest of all time and witness me ****ting on him for it.

I have no bias on Floyd...what.so.ever.


And let me know when you find me saying Floyd BLEW OUT Oscar...

I'll wait...

[-EX-]

You thought that Cotto vs Mosley was razor thin and now Floyd blew Oscar out. Floyd vs Oscar was much closer than Cotto vs Mosley. I think your bias is starting to show.

No it wasn't. Some people thought Shane won that fight. No way in hell did Oscar win 7 rounds against Floyd...I'm not sayin Floyd skooled Oscar though.

[oldgringo]

Miguel Cotto's last 3 fights

Alfonso Gomez W
Antonio Margarito L
Michael Jennings W

Floyd Mayweather's last 3 fights

Ricky Hatton (Undefeated) W
Oscar De La Hoya (#1 JMW at the time) W
Carlos Baldomir (#1 WW at the time) W

Battling Nelson, my friend, what has Cotto done to prove himself as a top WW?

He fought and beat other top 10 Welterweights. Do you really not know that? Mosley, Margarito, Judah, Quintana...........

[HK45]

Miguel Cotto's last 3 fights

Alfonso Gomez W
Antonio Margarito L
Michael Jennings W

Floyd Mayweather's last 3 fights

Ricky Hatton (Undefeated) W
Oscar De La Hoya (#1 JMW at the time) W
Carlos Baldomir (#1 WW at the time) W

Battling Nelson, my friend, what has Cotto done to prove himself as a top WW?

Ricky Hatton overated junior welterweight
Old Oscar De La Hoya beat down by pac, sd by Floyd
Carlos Baldomir a bum who was at the right place at the right time.

Alfonso Gomez much deserved easy fight after fighting Judah and Mosley
Margarito needed plaster to beat Cotto
Micheal Jennings much deserved tune up after being cheated by Plasterito

Who has Floyd beat at WW to claim he's a top WW when Cotto has by far outperformed him at WW?

[-EX-]

Miguel Cotto's last 3 fights

Alfonso Gomez W
Antonio Margarito L
Michael Jennings W

Floyd Mayweather's last 3 fights

Ricky Hatton (Undefeated) W
Oscar De La Hoya (#1 JMW at the time) W
Carlos Baldomir (#1 WW at the time) W

Battling Nelson, my friend, what has Cotto done to prove himself as a top WW?

Well he beat your boy Mosley and also beat Quintana. Only thing on him is that he lost Margarito. You gotta say Cotto is a top WW IMO. Either him or Mosley.

[THE REED]

Ricky Hatton overated junior welterweight
Old Oscar De La Hoya beat down by pac, sd by Floyd
Carlos Baldomir a bum who was at the right place at the right time.

Alfonso Gomez much deserved easy fight after fighting Judah and Mosley
Margarito needed plaster to beat Cotto
Micheal Jennings much deserved tune up after being cheated by Plasterito

Who has Floyd beat at WW to claim he's a top WW when Cotto has by far outperformed him at WW?

Ricky Hatton overated junior welterweight

Lets not forget how overrated he was BEFORE the fight... he wasn't.

Old Oscar De La Hoya beat down by pac, sd by Floyd

lets forget about Floyd fighting him at JR MW.. and Oscar killing himself to make 147 for pac... that never happened.

Carlos Baldomir a bum who was at the right place at the right time.

He was still the LINEAL champ period.. and if Floyd wanted to be the LINEAL champ... guess who he had to beat?


Guess what? I think your Floyd bias is showing.

[oldgringo]

And right on cue, as expected, this thread turns into "bias", "overrated", "hater", etc. Perfect.