why is floyd critisied at welter so damn much???

[Left Hook Tua]

So maybe Cotto should fight Hatton or Pac at 160.

pac by brutal ko!

[a-raines21]

Clottey, Cotto and Mosley all deserve a shot at Mayweather. To say he doesn't need to fight Cotto or Clottey but fighting JMM is ok is ridiculous.

He'd get so much more respect if he beat those 3 WW's.

he would get respect for beating marg, who is a **** fighter? jmm is a much better win imo..... marg is slow, and really cant win unless you run from him (just ask cotto)

clottey has not showed me anything other than the ability to beat zab judah (like everybody else) why does he get a shot?

cotto, you could argue, but seeing as he lost to a **** fighter, that an arguement that you very well may lose....

the point in jmm is on the top of his game, and looked at as maybe the best in the sport.... he is a much better win than may beating the bigger guys, becuse you all are looking more at the size, than the actual skills.....

[Ch@mpBox@PR]

floyd mayweather is better than any ww to ever come out of pr..... can you really argue that?

how would cotto or quintana do at 160? that would be their 4th weight class so how would they do?

Benitez in his prime would of made Floyd look like a fool.

And the later I already adressed that. If you start reading posts and stop nuthugging some much you would of seen it already!!!

[a-raines21]

you're right.

pac's tuneup against diaz should be compared to floyd's best win at 147 against carlos baldomir.

or against the guy who stands a great chance at kicking his ass on may 2.....

[Mersey]

he would get respect for beating marg, who is a **** fighter? jmm is a much better win imo..... marg is slow, and really cant win unless you run from him (just ask cotto)

clottey has not showed me anything other than the ability to beat zab judah (like everybody else) why does he get a shot?

cotto, you could argue, but seeing as he lost to a **** fighter, that an arguement that you very well may lose....

the point in jmm is on the top of his game, and looked at as maybe the best in the sport.... he is a much better win than may beating the bigger guys, becuse you all are looking more at the size, than the actual skills.....

I didn't mention Marg.

Cotto lost to a boxer with plaster in his gloves you can't bring that up.

Floyd is a WW, therefore, he should fight the best WW out there, thats why they all deserve a shot. If he's the best WW, he should clear up the division, not fight LWW's.

[a-raines21]

Benitez in his prime would of made Floyd look like a fool.

And the later I already adressed that. If you start reading posts and stop nuthugging some much you would of seen it already!!!

lol at that statment.....

[AntDawg]

I don't know man. I guess I can forgive him for the Sharmba Mitchell fight.

I mean why not fight Mitchell after Kostya Tzyu damn near beheaded him.


The thing I don't like is, holding up Baldomir's belt, like Baldomir was something.

It would be the same if Chad Dawson beat Zsolt Erdei. Nobody would give a **** because they know he isn't the best.

He gets major points for beating Hatton at welter.

But if he is naturally 135 or 140, frigging fight there.

But Baldomir was the champion at Welterweight at the time after he beat the undisputed Champ....

[Left Hook Tua]

or against the guy wh stad a great chance at kicking his ass on may 2.....

not really.

quit bigging up carlos to make floyd look better , man.



hell even david diaz beat zab once. lol

[a-raines21]

I didn't mention Marg.

Cotto lost to a boxer with plaster in his gloves you can't bring that up.

Floyd is a WW, therefore, he should fight the best WW out there, thats why they all deserve a shot. If he's the best WW, he should clear up the division, not fight LWW's.

although i believe marg cheated, it hasnt been proven, so you have to bring it up.... And fighters fight outside of their weightclass all the time..... would you not have givin hagler credit for beating srl?

do you discredit hopkins for beating trinidad and pavlik?

[a-raines21]

So maybe Cotto should fight Hatton or Pac at 160.

or maybe he shouldnt fight pac at all.... hatton at 160 would simply be a battle of the fat-asses