why is floyd critisied at welter so damn much???

[boxasmash]

cotto beat mosley, close fight but he won.

i dont think anyone really disputes that? cotto took far more risks than floyd, floyd is scared to lose his 0.

[Guest]

It's the same as saying that a win over Erdei is better than a win over Calzaghe/Hopkins.

Agree completely Bat and I also said this earlier. Zsolt Erdei is linear but no one would get credit for beating him.

(well maybe that Romanian dude would in Romania)

[boxasmash]

o.... cotto took a risk..... everytime a fighter fights, its a risk...... damn this **** is seriously out of hand

because fighting sharmba mitchell, zab judah and ricky hatton at 147 is real risky huh.

[Bushbaby]

The Punisher,he's only been in 3 divisions,but he'll fight everyone in those divisions though,everyone knows floyd is good,but his lack of defining fights are keeping him from being great,compairing him to SLR is crazy,no one on Floyd's resume can be compared to Duran,Hearns,Benitez,or Hagler,the closest u get is DLH and if he isnt that high on the atg list,how will floyd be that much higher!!

[PAC-BOY]

damn you don't know? If you rally don't that answer Please find a hobby777 You Know The answer L

[Luis12]

cotto beat mosley, close fight but he won.

i dont think anyone really disputes that? cotto took far more risks than floyd, floyd is scared to lose his 0.

agreed

The Punisher,he's only been in 3 divisions,but he'll fight everyone in those divisions though,everyone knows floyd is good,but his lack of defining fights are keeping him from being great,compairing him to SLR is crazy,no one on Floyd's resume can be compared to Duran,Hearns,Benitez,or Hagler,the closest u get is DLH and if he isnt that high on the atg list,how will floyd be that much higher!!

co-sign

[a-raines21]

because fighting sharmba mitchell, zab judah and ricky hatton at 147 is real risky huh.

yea it is..... pac-man wasnt suppose to be a risk for odlh..... but he was wasnt he?

[2501]

What weight does Floyd want JMM at again? And whats the reason Floyd fans say Floyd shouldnt have to fight Cotto, Mosley, Williams?

[MANGLER]

Cuz he refuses to fight the top WW's, that's why. Larry you just got back homey. Dead the hostile 'leave Mr boat buyer alone' threads bro. It's the 1 strike you got against you on here man, and I don't wanna see you get banned again for gettin pissed and lashin out at cats wit a bunch of these threads.

[Rompeboca]

he claims hes the best welter but wants to fight TWO lightweights as you just said.

go figure.

Very true!!!!