Who gets more credit for a win over Hatton. Floyd or Pac?

[THE REED]

Mayweather fight night weight was 148, Oscar was 166.
Pacman was 148 and Oscar was 147
I think PBF fought the healthy version and should get credit since he was the smaller man in the fight. But Pacman did move up but doesn’t change the fact he fought a weight drained Oscar





Pacman destroyed a weight drained Oscar. Roach commented on Oscar being weight drained. If anyone who really thinks Pacman fought a non-weight drained Oscar, They are either pure natural haters or very delusional individuals.

he was weight drained, just as much as pac was a blown up 130lb fighter, fighting at 147...

that fight had to do with manny as much as it did oscar


Floyd hasnt fought at 140 in 4+ years, let alone 130lbs... manny is smaller then Floyd, no ifs ands or buts about it

[Rich Loc]

he was weight drained, just as much as pac was a blown up 130lb fighter, fighting at 147...

that fight had to do with manny as much as it did oscar


Floyd hasnt fought at 140 in 4+ years, let alone 130lbs... manny is smaller then Floyd, no ifs ands or buts about it

What do you mean blown up 130 fighter?? He can’t make 135 anymore yet alone 130. His fight night weight at 135 shows that Pacman is the same weight as PBF fight night.

The fight had WAY MORE to do with Oscar than Manny. The man was weight drained. I even like Paulie M chances against that version of Oscar


Yes PBF is bigger than Manny. But it’s marginal.

[THE REED]

What do you mean blown up 130 fighter?? He can’t make 135 anymore yet alone 130. His fight night weight at 135 shows that Pacman is the same weight as PBF fight night.

The fight had WAY MORE to do with Oscar than Manny. The man was weight drained. I even like Paulie M chances against that version of Oscar


Yes PBF is bigger than Manny. But it’s marginal.

You think Manny cant make 135lbs?

wow... ok flawless...

[VaBoriKua 2.0]

Mayweather fight night weight was 148, Oscar was 166.
Pacman was 148 and Oscar was 147
I think PBF fought the healthy version and should get credit since he was the smaller man in the fight. But Pacman did move up but doesn’t change the fact he fought a weight drained Oscar





Pacman destroyed a weight drained Oscar. Roach commented on Oscar being weight drained. If anyone who really thinks Pacman fought a non-weight drained Oscar, They are either pure natural haters or very delusional individuals.

Lets see if we can get this in your ******ed ass skull. Pac basically went up 3 weight classes he didnt fight tune ups at the weight he didnt get his body to fight at that weight he just went up and said ill fight the best. Floyd was established at the weight already. Pac was the underdog everyone though he was gon get ko'd. Floyd every one though he was gon win and win big. Pacman demolished him and made him look like junk(weight drained or not) Floys bearly won a split decision which in my opinion he woulda lost if oscar would have kept throwing the jab. He might have been younger but he was still shot and no where near the oscar of old. Everyone even you said oscar would win at 147 so dont come up with ur excuses now.

[VaBoriKua 2.0]

You think Manny cant make 135lbs?

wow... ok flawless...

your talking to an idiot you can have a better conversation talking to the wall than you can with flawless

[deevel79]

We also have to consider the approach each fighter took against Oscar.

Floyd played it safe, and resorted to pot-shotting, playing defense, and countering here and there.

Pac went in there to take Oscar out from the get-go. His intentions were to not leave it in the judges hands.

[fdotorres]

is this even a question?

hatton has now a better trainer. he's also fighting at his best (140)

also, pac is a guy that has jumped how many weight classes? his last four fights are in different weights (going up and down against naturals in those weights, except oscar at 147)

he deserves a LOT more credit

[Rich Loc]

Lets see if we can get this in your ******ed ass skull. Pac basically went up 3 weight classes he didnt fight tune ups at the weight he didnt get his body to fight at that weight he just went up and said ill fight the best

Pacman went up 2 weight classes. PBF didn't have a tune fight at 154 also. Oscar was not even ranked at WW and has not fought there since 2001. Floyd beat Oscar at 154. At the time Oscar was number ranked Jr MW in the world. Also won a belt as well

Pacman demolished him and made him look like junk(weight drained or not) Floys bearly won a split decision which in my opinion he woulda lost if oscar would have kept throwing the jab

So you agree, Pacman did beat a weight drained Oscar. Roach himself said Oscar was dead at that weight. Maybe it was Mayweather's skills that stopped Oscar jab. Oscar stopped jabbing when PBF started connecting with solid right hands

He might have been younger but he was still shot and no where near the oscar of old. Everyone even you said oscar would win at 147 so dont come up with ur excuses now

Yea. I didn't know Oscar was going to be weight drained, now did I.

[Rich Loc]

We also have to consider the approach each fighter took against Oscar.

Floyd played it safe, and resorted to pot-shotting, playing defense, and countering here and there.

Pac went in there to take Oscar out from the get-go. His intentions were to not leave it in the judges hands.

Let’s take into consideration the weight Oscar was fight night.

Mayweather fought Oscar that weighed 166 poubds, while Pacman fought 147 Oscar. 19 pounds difference.

Mayweather fight night weight was 148, the exact same as Pac

[deevel79]

Let’s take into consideration the weight Oscar was fight night.

Mayweather fought Oscar that weighed 166 poubds, while Pacman fought 147 Oscar. 19 pounds difference.

Mayweather fight night weight was 148, the exact same as Pac

Like Floyd himself said: "weight dont win fights. Skills do"