Who gets more credit for a win over Hatton. Floyd or Pac?

[warp1432]

Of those 2 fights at 147, one was a loss and the other was a contraversial win. Hatton has the weight to compete at 147, just not the height or reach.

Does he at 140 either?

[-MAKAVELLI-]

after PAC obliterates Hatton, there wouldnt be any questions

[Ch@mpBox@PR]

Pacquiao, because he will be moving up to fight the lineal champ at his best weight!!!!!!1

[THE REED]

after PAC obliterates Hatton, there wouldnt be any questions

word to your mother, son.

[THE REED]

Pacquiao, because he will be moving up to fight the lineal champ at his best weight!!!!!!1

He'll be moving down actually! yes! down! actually!

[deevel79]

No, I don't believe I said that?

Hang on let me go check..........



.................................................. .................






...................











Nope! Didn't say that!

I dont buy the height or reach deal... ..

I take this as you saying height and reach dont benefit a fighter. If i'm wrong, please explain. I say that i dont feel hatton has the height or reach to be competitive in the WW division, and your response was "I dont buy the height or reach deal"

[THE REED]

I take this as you saying height and reach dont benefit a fighter. If i'm wrong, please explain. I say that i dont feel hatton has the height or reach to be competitive in the WW division, and your response was "I dont buy the height or reach deal"

Thank you for telling me what you and I both said. If you hadn't done that, I might not of remembered the specifics of our encounter about three minutes ago...

What Im saying is, it isn't the height or reach, he doesn't possess the power or strength to "bully" true welterweights around... and personally thats all he has going for him in my opinion...

Sorry for being a **** about a paragraph ago. I love you deevel.

[Cortezsucks]

Pac!

Its Hattons weight and hopefully Bayliss will not pull a Cortez.

[MACAQUEINBLACK]

Hatton is essentially Floyd's leftovers now

he's been awfull since, and i reckon it ****ed his mind up

I agree to an extent. The kind of systematic pounding Mayweather handed Ricky takes something out of a fighter, and you can't factor that out of the final assessment.


It depends as well on if Ricky presents the same kind of unique stylistic challenge to Pac as he did to Floyd. If Ricky fights with (is allowed to fight with) the style that can win him the fight, it's all the more remarkable if Pac pulls it off, because I'm not sure I see Manny first being able to stop Ricky getting inside and second being able to counteract what he does when he gets there. If Ricky fights in the more measured pace and style he did against Malignaggi, I see Pac's job being made a lot easier.

For Ricky's part, if he beats Manny in a clean technical performance without a hell of a lot of dirt, I will be shocked and hail him.

[AssasinKing]

Besides the fact people are saying Hatton has got better, im not convinced how much better you can get in such little time...but im not doubting him being able to do it

Back on the subject i think, pacman would get more credit...the fight is at light welter..the weight hatton has always claimed he is the best in the world at. Also if there is no question marks over the referee then if pacman beats him he will have way more credit for doing it...

Floyd has been tryin to get people out of their comfort zone....even what hes tryin with JMM rite now lol