Does big Paul Williams crack your top 10 pound 4 pound list now??

[Burner]

Top 6 easily.

Hes one of the best fighters in the world without a doubt..

He just put the boxing word on notice....when Winky last lost he was a top 5 p4pounder and Paul butt ****ed him.

[egreezy]

There will be a few who find reasons not to. But the Ring had him #10 before he got his interim belt @154. So that plus a win over Winky I could see him in the 5-10 range on various ppls list.

[Jim Jeffries]

Why does Darchinyan have to be kicked off???

I personally think Ricky Hatton or Celestino Caballero should be off. Darchinyan should be higher than 10.

I see P-Will at the 8 spot.

Off the top of my head I would have it like this:
Pacquiao
Marquez
Hopkins
Vazquez
Mosley
Marquez
Darchinyan
P. Williams
Calderon
Caballero

Not a bad list, but I'd have to wait until after the Pac fight to kick Hatton off of there. Tough having Mosley that many spots above Cotto for me as well.

[egreezy]

I took Vasquez off my list he's practically retired from injury and has nothing else lined up.

[IMDAZED]

Hatton shouldn't be in the top ten. I mean...seriously. Maybe he beats Pac and proves otherwise but right now...no way. Pound for pound? I'd take Williams' win over an aged but still good Winky over Hatton's win over...who? Oh right, a young Kostya Tszyu.

[Kevin Jesus]

Paul Williams has to be top 10 no doubt about it, he just beat up a guy who couldn't find a fight realistically because no one wanted to fight him;not because he didn't want to fight anyone for 2 years.

[ИATAS]

Not a bad list, but I'd have to wait until after the Pac fight to kick Hatton off of there. Tough having Mosley that many spots above Cotto for me as well.

**** I completely forgot about cotto!

Good point about Hatton/Pacman, but I'm convinced he's going to get TKO'd. Cotto needs to on the list, Caballero should also be booted for now...

[RightCross94]

1. Pacquiao
2. JM Marquez
3. Hopkins
4. Mosley
5. Darchinyan
6. Calderon
7. Paul Williams
8. Celestino Cabarello
9. Israel Vazquez
10. Rafa Marquez

I would rate Vazquez and Marquez a bit higher if they had fought more recently, i understand the trilogy was bruising and they needed the layoff, but that comes at a cost and their places should drop a bit. I also am starting to have doubts as to if they will fight again....I heard somewhere Rafa started training again and experienced dizziness etc in the gym. Plus those 3 fights werent the first hard fights for either of those dudes.

[Skylight]

1.Manny Pacquiao
2.Juan Manuel Marquez
3.Bernard Hopkins
4.Shane Mosley
5.Miguel Cotto
6.Ivan Calderon
7.Wladimir Klitsko
8.Paul Williams
9.Israel
10.Vic

[Piggu]

Maybe around 9 or 10.