How highly do you regard Shane Mosley?

[Silencers]

I think he's a lock for the HOF, not really an ATG but a very, very good fighter nonetheless.

[Zocalo]

Shane is one of the better fighters of his generation, but somewhere short of the Hall of Fame.

He never dominated a weight class, but he did have a deserved stint atop the p4p rankings. The only top fighter he ever dominated was Margarito, and that carries an asterisk.

He got legitimately beat by Winky, Forrest and Cotto. Forrest and Cotto were in his best weight class.

What an obtuse post...

[winac]

What an obtuse post...

Obtuse??? Do you mean astute?

[boxasmash]

top 5 of his era, definite ATG.

above oscar and trinidad.

[Rich Loc]

Mosley ranks higher than Tito and Oscar

Oscar has A LOT of questionable decisions

[this is nove]

I dont know where i would rank mosley on my atg list but he definitly is up there as one of my favorites to watch.he has fast hands and he is never afraid to let them go. He always in great shape and always a stand up guy. He has beaten and lost to formidable and credible opponents. And if you dont believe that styles make fights take in consideration mosley has knocked out fernando vargas(twice) ricardo mayorga and antonio margarito these are men who hold victories over the men that has handed mosley his losses vernon forrest ronald wright and miguel cotto. Shane mosley definitly one of my favorites of all time.

[talip bin osman]

cliff rold pretty much sums it up here...

http://www.boxingscene.com/?m=show&id=18011

this was before the margarito fight...


i guess mosley's stature will grow in time...

[IMDAZED]

Lol, he may have been given the decision but not because he "beat" Oscar. Oscar gave the fight away. I still remember the look on Tito's face when the decision was announced. He was more than surprised. He knew he got a gift. Despite that decision the public definitely knew who the better fighter was.

Well if Oscar decided to give the fight away that means the other guy won. It's almost assured in boxing that if you lose your balls in the middle of the fight you're probably gonna lose the fight as well.

[daggum]

Well if Oscar decided to give the fight away that means the other guy won. It's almost assured in boxing that if you lose your balls in the middle of the fight you're probably gonna lose the fight as well.

not true at all. calzaghe is 46-0.

[Horus]

PERFORMING ENHANCING DRUGS A.K.A STEROIDS

NO Hall of Fame FOR CHEATERS.

I will not let mosely off the hook for this. Too me the only reason he beat Oscar was because he cheated. Imagine How much that win would have done for Oscar career and that lost to Mosely career.