Antonio Margarito on Mexico's All-Time list?

[IwatchBoxing]

Basora was also beaten by a lot of boxers other than Robinson and LaMotta...

He did have great moments during his career but it's not as if he bested Robinson or LaMotta, he lost the series to both of them (which is no shame since they were great fighters).

I would place him on my list but everyone's record can be picked apart just as you are picking apart the resumes of Rosario, Camacho and Serrano. They were accomplished fighters.

So, how do you make a top ten list !!!

You have to pick apart !!

LOLOLOLOLOL

Do a list, mine is far better than Saddo, you see, PR lists are all F'ed up, purposely to blind people searching for the thurth, I seen Champions list, boy he feel bad seeing them have Trinidad at 11 LOLOLOL

[TheGreatA]

So, how do you make a top ten list !!!

You have to pick apart !!

LOLOLOLOLOL

Do a list, mine is far better than Saddo, you see, PR lists are all F'ed up, purposely to blind people searching for the thurth, I seen Champions list, boy he feel bad seeing them have Trinidad at 11 LOLOLOL

What I'm saying is that you're not picking them apart in a good way, for others such as DeLeon (who did not really fight anyone with a name) you'd point out to his record of titles held and defended but for Serrano or Rosario you'd say that they never fought anybody (even though they fought a similar/higher level of competition of DeLeon).

That's just my opinion. I'm not saying that your list is bad but you asked for people's opinions about your list and I gave you mine.

[IwatchBoxing]

What I'm saying is that you're not picking them apart in a good way, for others such as DeLeon (who did not really fight anyone with a name) you'd point out to his record of titles held and defended but for Serrano or Rosario you'd say that they never fought anybody (even though they fought a similar/higher level of competition of DeLeon).

That's just my opinion. I'm not saying that your list is bad but you asked for people's opinions about your list and I gave you mine.

De Leon was ranked where, when (Boxingscene)they made their top cruiserweights of all time?

[TheGreatA]

De Leon was ranked where, when (Boxingscene)they made their top cruiserweights of all time?

Number 2.

The cruiserweight division is a notoriously weak division and relatively new compared to the others. DeLeon held titles for many years but he lost to his best opponents and some mediocre ones as well.

Not that DeLeon wasn't a good fighter but Rosario beat better names than he did while Serrano made more title defenses than he did. You would have to rank the three pretty close to each other based on this.

[IwatchBoxing]

#2 all time Cruiserweight

I dont see how you could compare them, to him.

[TheGreatA]

#2 all time Cruiserweight

I dont see how you could compare them, to him.

Johnny Nelson is the number 3 greatest cruiserweight according to that list.

He probably doesn't make the top 25 greatest British fighters.

[IwatchBoxing]

Number 2.

The cruiserweight division is a notoriously weak division and relatively new compared to the others. DeLeon held titles for many years but he lost to his best opponents and some mediocre ones as well.

Not that DeLeon wasn't a good fighter but Rosario beat better names than he did while Serrano made more title defenses than he did.

So did Hector Camacho, but he wasn't listed either, I listed Camacho because he was better than Edwin, and not basing it on one fight.

That is still an accomplishment, I hear Ricardo Lopez was in a weak divsion too, but is ranked very highly.

[IwatchBoxing]

Johnny Nelson is the number 3 greatest cruiserweight.

He probably doesn't make the top 25 greatest British fighters list.

Than who does? I dont know anything about British fighters, sorry other than Lennox Lewis, Ricky Hatton, Nicky Cook, and David Haye (one of my favorites)

[TheGreatA]

Than who does? I dont know anything about British fighters, sorry other than Lennox Lewis, Ricky Hatton, Nicky Cook, and David Haye (one of my favorites)

Not my official list but here are a couple of names that I'd consider better than Johnny Nelson:

Lennox Lewis
Jimmy Wilde
Bob Fitzsimmons
Joe Calzaghe
Ted 'Kid' Lewis
Ken Buchanan
Freddie Welsh
Jim Driscoll
Randy Turpin
Naseem Hamed
Ricky Hatton
Barry McGuigan
Chris Eubank
Nigel Benn
Freddie Mills
Lloyd Honeyghan
Howard Winstone
Benny Lynch
Owen Moran
Jackie Berg
Terry Downes
John Conteh

[IwatchBoxing]

Not my official list but here are a couple of names that I'd consider better than Johnny Nelson:

Lennox Lewis
Jimmy Wilde
Bob Fitzsimmons
Joe Calzaghe
Ted 'Kid' Lewis
Ken Buchanan
Freddie Welsh
Jim Driscoll
Randy Turpin
Naseem Hamed
Ricky Hatton
Barry McGuigan
Chris Eubank
Nigel Benn
Freddie Mills
Lloyd Honeyghan
Howard Winstone
Benny Lynch
Owen Moran
Jackie Berg
Terry Downes
John Conteh

Joe Calzaghe

right, right....