Can Floyd Mayweather be considered a HOF'er and ATG?

[ALT=_=Assassin]

Mayweaher is an ATG Top 20, it's just these forums he is bashed on because it's dominated by racist Mexican and many white supremacists.

Mayweather is undefeated at 5 weight classes. Fought the best at 130,135,147 and 154. All were ranked as ring number one at the time. Most of his fights, pretty much all. Mayweather is the smaller guy yet still wins. The greatest 130 fighter of all time. Without doubt the most skilled boxer of all time

My brother Flawed speaks the truth, these whiteys don't know what a great fighter is. The best they could come up with is Rocky Ballsboa.

Black Power, Alija Mohammad Alija


End/sarcasm

[BattlingNelson]

Are we talking Top 50 ATG or Top 100 ATG?

Defining all-time-greatness is subjective to say say the least. I think it would be ATG in the eye of the beholder as it could be argued that there might not even be 100 ATG fighters as well as it could be said that there's 500.

[Sugar May Floyd]

My brother Flawed speaks the truth, these whiteys don't know what a great fighter is. The best they could come up with is Rocky Ballsboa.

Black Power, Alija Mohammad Alija


End/sarcasm

A Calzaghe fan talking ***ing hilarious

[Drunk Punch]

HoF and ATG?

Hell yes.

[ALT=_=Assassin]

A Calzaghe fan talking ***ing hilarious

I can appreciate the fact that he ranks as a top 100 ATG and is number one at his weightclass.... Not a fan tho....

[CRESCENDOPOWER]

Top 25-40? Seriously? And how on earth is he only one step below the Fab 4 in accomplishment. SRL has wins over Benitez, Duran, Hearns and Hagler. Mayweather doesn't come close when considering accomplishments

The exact reason why I don't put him on the same level as the Fab 4. When he moved up in weight he did not even try to challenge the top level of competition. I am a full-blown Floyd Mayweather Jr. hater, but I am not ******, or completely blind.

[TheGreatA]

Mayweaher is an ATG Top 20, it's just these forums he is bashed on because it's dominated by racist Mexican and many white supremacists.

Mayweather is undefeated at 5 weight classes. Fought the best at 130,135,147 and 154. All were ranked as ring number one at the time. Most of his fights, pretty much all. Mayweather is the smaller guy yet still wins. The greatest 130 fighter of all time. Without doubt the most skilled boxer of all time

What's this?

Whitaker > Pep > Mayweather > Bentiez > Prime Ali

It's so sad that one of the best fighters I've ever seen cannot be considered an ATG.

It depends on who you consider an all-time great or not.

I agree that he is one of the most skilled fighters there was but he could've done so much more in my opinion.

[Sugar May Floyd]

I can appreciate the fact that he ranks as a top 100 ATG and is number one at his weightclass.... Not a fan tho....

and Mayweather doesn't???

[Sugar May Floyd]

What's this?





It depends on who you consider an all-time great or not.

I agree that he is one of the most skilled fighters there was but he could've done so much more in my opinion.

That was about the best defensive fighter of all time, not skill

[ALT=_=Assassin]

and Mayweather doesn't???

Mayweather pales in comparison to Joe The Magnificent Calzaghe.

End/sarcasm