Should Miguel Cotto be given his 0 back?

[The Rican]

Seriously, should he?

I say yes for the obvious reasons.

Agree? Disagree?

Why?

[Please avoid the redundant "there is no way to prove he did it against Cotto" arguement we are past that people. He's been found guilty which makes it that much more likely that he actually did do it. So lets have an intelligent discussion and not talk in circles. Thanks.]

[RL_GMA]

I think it's one of those things in Boxing that'll never be answered, but everyone will have a "strong" opinion about it (especially if they never fight again).

[Fenom]

if Margaritos found guilty of using banned wraps in their first fight?

i seriously would petition for it

[Sweet Pea 50]

What a great thread. How about

[IMG]http://i20.***********.com/albums/b213/NROOF13/stfu.jpg[/IMG]

and be like Cotto, and handle the **** with CLASS.

[Ch@mpBox@PR]

Nope. he should get a NC. Cotto didnt won the fight to get a W on his record!!!!!!!

[williamhvx1]

nah ... as puertorican... he dint have the right fight plan, regardless margacheato cheating dilema....

[hammerhiem]

No, you can't change past results without clear evidence or admittion of guilt.

[Underdog82]

No, even though I firmly believe that Margarito was cheating with the glove thing, I also believe that he still would have won without it. Cotto was gassed and hurting bad from his own offense.

[Jay Lavoe]

I would like to think it was all a misunderstanding so we can all see the rematch but if Margarito admitts his hands are wrapped the same for every fight then yes I would petition it but I think at this point cotto is more focused on avenging his loss then getting it taken off. Also at the same time plaster or not he was overwhelmed with the pressure and like he said it was Margaritos night.

[Derranged]

Seriously, should he?

I say yes for the obvious reasons.

Agree? Disagree?

Why?

[Please avoid the redundant "there is no way to prove he did it against Cotto" arguement we are past that people. He's been found guilty which makes it that much more likely that he actually did do it. So lets have an intelligent discussion and not talk in circles. Thanks.]

The problem is, THERE IS NO WAY TO PROVE IT. And to overturn the fight, thats what you would need. PROOF. Its not redundant. Its the hard truth of the matter.