Is Joe Calzaghe a top 50 ATG?

[KnockoutTheFat]

Does he crack the top 50? Vote and discuss.

[Ch@mpBox@PR]

Does he crack the top 50? Vote and discuss.

Nope. he is top 100, but not top 50. his skill suggests top 50, but his resume, says top 100. he should be rank around 92 ATG!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!

[The Gunner]

Fighters ratings go up more long after they are gone. 10 years from now he will be.

[Dan...]

Personally I don't think he is top 50. Top 100 definately but not top 50 IMO. There have just been too many amazing fighters.

[larryx]

hell naw...

[Left Hook Tua]

fuck no.

hell fucking no.

[The Gunner]

Marciano was never highly rated after he left the sport yet he pushes top 20 ATG all these years later. Marciano was always stuck in Joe Louis shadow, even after he beat him.

I have a feeling history will be kind to Calzaghe....Starting when he's inducted into the HOF first ballot.

[larryx]

he aint even top 100..maybe top 150-200

[Left Hook Tua]

hagler , greb , robinson , monzon , tiger , fullmer , ketchel , jones , hopkins , mccallum , nunn , lamotta , maxim , moore , foster , tunney , fitzsimmons , conn , spinks , moorer.

that's 20 guys right there who are all better than calzaghe who fought from 160-175.


what about all the great welterweights? lightweights? featherweights? heavyweights?

please...... calzaghe's resume is a joke.

[CarsonCALI]

if the list is all time greatest ****tiest resume, than yes.