Joe Calzaghe >>> Hopkins and Roy Jones

[THE REED]

I swear you Calzaghe fans or British fans in general get me more aggravted than that one time a guy told me and seriously believed Miguel Cotto beat Roy Jones for a belt while I tried to tell him that wasn't possible because Jones is at 175 while Cotto was at 147. He kept insisting I was wrong. He also said the Cotto-Margarito fight was fixed, cause Cotto went down to his knees on "soft" shots. As a Cotto fan, He pissed me off. but damn you Calzaghe people are ridiciulous.

:rof:

[krispy kreme]

I swear you Calzaghe fans or British fans in general get me more aggravted than that one time a guy told me and seriously believed Miguel Cotto beat Roy Jones for a belt while I tried to tell him that wasn't possible because Jones is at 175 while Cotto was at 147. He kept insisting I was wrong. He also said the Cotto-Margarito fight was fixed, cause Cotto went down to his knees on "soft" shots. As a Cotto fan, He pissed me off. but damn you Calzaghe people are ridiciulous.

You should have followed him home and finished the job god began.

[The Gunner]

Calzaghe's career isn't 1/3 what Roy's or Hopkins' is. And I truly believe that. He has accomplished jack **** in this sport.

Yet he holds wins over both and the record books will always show it. LOL!

[DiegoFuego]

Yet he holds wins over both and the record books will always show it. LOL!

And Trevor Berbick has a victory over Muhammad Ali. What's your point?

[The Gunner]

And Trevor Berbick has a victory over Muhammad Ali. What's your point?

Horrible comparison....Ali had Parkinsons when he fought Berbik, he was beyond shot.

Calzaghe was also past his best when he beat both.

[Zocalo]

Um Ok... great thread.

[77Ritchie77]

at 168 calzaghe has the best resume ever. only guy to win all 4 belts.
also he conquered america. hopkins and jones in vegas and new york.
hopkins' resume at middleweight wasn't all that good either. id say hopkins at middleweight is about equal to joe at supermiddle.
hopkins' best win was against trinidad, not as good as kessler
hopkins' second best win was ODLH( at middle wtf?) about as good as lacy?

above middleweight, calzaghe beat hopkins and roy jones.
hopkins beat winky, tarver, and pavlik and lost to joe. - to be fair; tarver is **** and hopkins fought winky and pavlik out of their natural divisions, giving him an advantage.

jones basically has two careers, one of the greatest ever, and a fringe contender career afterwards.

verdict: its hard to say any of these guys are clearly greater than eachother.

[Guest]

Calzaghe is Superior

UNDEFEATED

46-0, 32 KO's

Greatest Super Middleweight of all time

Undisputed Super Middleweight Champ

Undisputed Light Heavyweight Champ


All of the jealous racist Calzaghe haters can go fuck themselves!

In your face bitches!!!

Great post.
Calzaghe ATG.
Y'all must've forgot.

[Guest]

And Trevor Berbick has a victory over Muhammad Ali. What's your point?

That's irrelevant.
Calzaghe is undefeated, unlike Ali, or Trevor for that matter.

[El Dominicano]

You should have followed him home and finished the job god began.

LOL