Joe Calzaghe >>> Hopkins and Roy Jones

[dde91]

Calzaghe=Overrated

[larryx]

Really.

So floyd mayweather was undisputed welterweight champ then when he beat baldomir?

baldo beat judah who was undisputed..calzaghe beat hopkins who beat tarver who beat jones..so yea he was undisputed

[VirusTI]

Your a ***ing fool, please take Klitschko of your sig, it gives Slavs a bad name

[larryx]

How am I being racist?

man i agree with alot you say..but calzaghes career was not better than hopkins or jones noway no how..hopkins was undisputed at 2 weight classes just like joe right???but has done more at 175 than joe..and roy jones went all the way to heavyweight..be real man

[-Antonio-]

You don't even believe this. Just like you try to convince yourself Wlad doesn't have a **** chin.

[El Dominicano]

Calzaghe is overated :wt:

[-Antonio-]

Calzaghe is overated :wt:

Reported for racism.

[billybilo]

There is too much emphasis on undefeated records considering that Calzaghe's resume pales in comparison to that of Hopkins and Roy Jones. Someone that didn't leave their homeland for 98% of his career will never be the "Greatest Super Middleweight" of all time.

Do you really have to leave you homeland to be considered "The Greatest"? If so, how often have Roy Jones and Bernard Hopkins left theirs?

The simple fact is, Joe never needed to go to America or anywhere else because he filled stadiums in Wales. Made loads of money, built up a fanbase, then beat 2 American greats in their home country. Not too bad if you ask me.

[El Dominicano]

Reported for racism.

Why would they have the smilies for?

[nujabes77]

well he beat both of them so i guess you can say owned. he's undefeated record is better than floyd as well and fought longer. i guess you can say calzaghe > roy/bhop/floyd