POLL: WHO WON - BERTO vs COLLAZO

Collapse
Collapse
  • Time
  • Show
Clear All
new posts
  • Njord777
    Archaic Pugilist
    Platinum Champion - 1,000-5,000 posts
    • May 2006
    • 2509
    • 177
    • 9
    • 8,928

    #61
    Collazo piled up the early rounds after losing the 1st. Yes, Berto had a late rally and def. took the last two rounds in my book but, with the point deduction and Collazo's early work I had him winning a razor thin decision.

    Comment

    • Kobe Bryant
      lefhooktodabody
      Super Champion - 5,000-10,000 posts
      • Sep 2006
      • 5319
      • 165
      • 2
      • 14,366

      #62
      I gave it to Berto. Rounds 1 and 12 were critical. And I thought Berto clearly took those rounds.

      Comment

      • savorduhflavor
        Undisputed Champion
        Super Champion - 5,000-10,000 posts
        • Oct 2008
        • 8194
        • 288
        • 59
        • 14,875

        #63
        Originally posted by lefhooktodabody
        I gave it to Berto. Rounds 1 and 12 were critical. And I thought Berto clearly took those rounds.
        I'm with you man. Round 1 was a Berto round.

        Comment

        • T-97
          BuyTheTicketTakeTheRide
          Unified Champion - 10,00-20,000 posts
          • Nov 2007
          • 14808
          • 566
          • 628
          • 22,958

          #64
          Originally posted by savorduhfalvor
          I'm with you man. Round 1 was a Berto round.
          Agreed.

          Collazo landed one big shot, but apart from that..it was all Berto. Berto even rocked Collazo a bit in the same round with a good right hand.

          Comment

          • Brandish
            Banned
            • Jul 2007
            • 2074
            • 153
            • 29
            • 2,273

            #65
            colllazo was after berto the whole fight, he never took a step back or showed that he was scared. in the first round if the ropes weren't close by berto would of fell.
            give him the rematch, hopefully somewhere up here, nyc or atlantic city...
            collazo lost because he gassed in the middle rounds..

            round 1-berto
            round 2- collazo
            round 3-berto
            round 4-collazo
            round 5-berto
            round 6-berto
            round 7-berto
            round 8-collazo
            round 9-collazo
            round 10-collazo
            round 11-berto
            round 12-berto

            with the 1 point deduction for holding you have it 7-6 berto or 114-113

            collazo needed to win the 11th and 12th but berto came back after the 10th and attacked collazo to the body again. the 12th was huge as berto's body shots almost got collazo out of there.

            Comment

            • jcarr71
              Undisputed Champion
              Platinum Champion - 1,000-5,000 posts
              • Jul 2006
              • 1040
              • 46
              • 2
              • 7,483

              #66
              I downloaded it this morning, watched it, and scored it before I knew there was going to be some controversy about it. I ended up with...

              1 - 10-9 collazo (10-9 Collazo)
              2 - 10-9 Berto (19-19 Even)
              3 - 10-10 Even (29-29 Even)
              4 - 10-8 Collazo (39-37 Collazo)
              5 - 10-9 Berto (48-47 Collazo)
              6 - 10-9 Collazo (58-56 Collazo)
              7 - 10-9 Berto (68-67 Collazo)
              8 - 10-9 Berto (77-77 Even)
              9 - 10-9 Collazo (87-86 Collazo)
              10 - 10-9 Collazo (97-95 Collazo)
              11 - 10-9 Berto (106-105 Collazo)
              12 - 10-9 Berto

              115-115, a draw.

              I also gave an even round in the third while the HBO crew thought Collazo won it in a landslide. Berto was being outlanded 2 to 1 but it looked to me that he was dishing out even damage so I scored it so. With the point deduction a win for Berto is a tough sell though. The rounds he lost were lost convincingly. I didn't like the call so if I didn't have to honor the deduction I'd have had Berto winning by a point, but that would be as far as you could rationally go. I don't think Collazo edged out a single of the close rounds on my card, so if you gave any one of those to Luis, or scored the third for him for volume, he wins.

              Comment

              • Savino
                Slaughterhouse
                Super Champion - 5,000-10,000 posts
                • Feb 2008
                • 7533
                • 390
                • 246
                • 16,452

                #67
                I just watched it now and I dont think the was a clear winner so I went with a draw. I can say that I doubt the will be a fight that can top that this year. i was impressed with both and looking forward to the rematch.

                Comment

                • Ch@mpBox@PR
                  Banned
                  Franchise Champion - 20,000+ posts
                  • Feb 2008
                  • 21432
                  • 432
                  • 279
                  • 22,261

                  #68
                  Originally posted by Brandish
                  collazo lost because he gassed in the middle rounds..

                  round 1-berto
                  round 2- collazo
                  round 3-berto
                  round 4-collazo
                  round 5-berto
                  round 6-berto
                  round 7-berto
                  round 8-collazo
                  round 9-collazo
                  round 10-collazo
                  round 11-berto
                  round 12-berto

                  with the 1 point deduction for holding you have it 7-6 berto or 114-113

                  collazo needed to win the 11th and 12th but berto came back after the 10th and attacked collazo to the body again. the 12th was huge as berto's body shots almost got collazo out of there.
                  how in hell you ave Berto the 3rd round. That was one of the rounds that Collazo won clearly!!!!!!!!

                  Comment

                  • larryx
                    Banned
                    Unified Champion - 10,00-20,000 posts
                    • May 2008
                    • 13892
                    • 225
                    • 108
                    • 15,442

                    #69
                    imma stick to my guns...great fight...but collazo won

                    Comment

                    • Johnny Rebel
                      Undisputed Champion
                      Platinum Champion - 1,000-5,000 posts
                      • Oct 2004
                      • 1651
                      • 79
                      • 190
                      • 7,877

                      #70
                      I thought Collazo won by a couple of points, but it was fairly close.

                      Max Kellerman (I hate that guy, he commentates like he's a nut-hugging troll on NSB) needs to STFU with the Collazo was "ripped off" against Hatton crap. Collazo wasn't "ripped" of, he just lost a close decision because Hatton won more rounds, scored a knockdown and outworked him. Just because LC had 2 really good rounds doesn't mean a judge can change how he scored the fight. If boxing had a "who do you think got the better of who in the fight" on scorecards then maybe Collazo could argue he won, but he still lost more rounds and was out worked and knocked down.

                      Comment

                      Working...
                      TOP